HMRC SDLT: SDLTM00415 – Scope: what is chargeable: land transactions: Residential Property–How many Dwellings? Forming a Balanced Judgement

Principles and Concepts of Chargeable Land Transactions

This section of the HMRC internal manual discusses the scope of chargeable land transactions, specifically focusing on residential property and determining the number of dwellings. It guides forming a balanced judgement on these matters.

• Explains the criteria for identifying chargeable land transactions.
• Focuses on residential properties and the assessment of dwellings.
• Provides guidance on forming balanced judgements in complex scenarios.
• Aims to ensure accurate tax assessments by HMRC.

Understanding Chargeable Land Transactions: How Many Dwellings?

This page was introduced on 01 October 2019.

Key Considerations for Determining Dwellings

When figuring out whether a property contains one or more dwellings, various factors need to be considered. It is important to understand that no single factor alone will usually make the decision clear-cut. However, not every factor carries the same importance. A strong factor can outweigh several weaker ones. Therefore, when faced with differing indicators, you may need to carefully weigh these elements to arrive at a fair conclusion.

Factors to Assess the Number of Dwellings

The following list highlights significant factors that should be evaluated in determining how many dwellings are part of a property. While this list covers major indicators often encountered, it is not exhaustive. Other relevant factors may also come into play.

– Purpose of Different Areas: Consider how different areas of the property are used. For instance, if part of the property has been converted into a self-contained flat with its own entrance, this could indicate there is more than one dwelling.

– Design and Structure: The physical setup of the property also matters. A large house with an adjoining guest suite might raise questions about whether these should be treated as distinct dwellings.

– Facilities and Amenities: Availability of separate living facilities such as kitchens and bathrooms could suggest multiple dwellings. Each living area should be assessed to see if it provides independent living conditions.

– Zoning and Planning Permissions: Local regulations can give clues about what is intended for the property. If planning permission has been granted for multiple units, this supports the notion that the property contains more than one dwelling.

– Historically Registered Use: The past use of the property can provide insight. If the property has been previously classified as containing multiple units or dwellings, this history should be taken into account.

Case Example: Guest Suites and Separate Living Spaces

Imagine a situation where a large family home includes an attached guest suite. If there is confusion about the total number of dwellings in this property, you will need to evaluate which conclusion matches the factual circumstances most accurately.

This scenario reinforces the need to look at the overall context. Just because one part of the home is being used as a guest suite does not automatically mean it counts as a separate dwelling unless it meets specific criteria.

Legal Interpretation of Dwellings

The term ‘suitable for use as a single dwelling’ has been examined in court, especially concerning tax matters related to Multiple Dwellings Relief (Schedule 6B FA2003). A case example is Fiander and Brower, [2021] UKUT156(TCC), which provides guidance on understanding this term.

According to this legal interpretation:

– An objective test is to be applied. The definition of a ‘dwelling’ needs to be based on whether it is fit for a general occupant, not just a specific type of person, such as a relative or someone squatting.

This establishes a clear standard: a dwelling should cater to common living requirements.

The Objective Observer Test

A useful approach when determining the number of dwellings is to consider how many dwellings an objective observer would identify in the property. This is known as “The objective observer test.”

– HMRC applies this test during compliance checks. The test ensures a fair assessment based on what an uninvolved person would reasonably conclude about the number of dwellings.

The First-tier tribunal encouraged this method, reinforcing that an impartial viewpoint is essential in these evaluations.

How HMRC Makes Assessments

Assessments made by HMRC involve a thorough evaluation of all relevant factors surrounding the property. Consider the following steps that HMRC follows:

– Collecting Information: Gather details about the property, including layout, structural features, and any historical use or developments.

– Analyzing Usage: Look at how different parts of the property are being used. Determine if different areas serve as distinct living spaces.

– Weighing Factors: After assembling all relevant information, HMRC weighs various factors. A strong indicator may significantly tilt the balance.

– Final Judgement: After careful consideration, HMRC arrives at a decision that reflects the overall facts and circumstances regarding the property.

Examples of Factors at Play

To understand better how various factors may affect the determination of dwellings, consider the following examples:

– Example 1: A converted barn that has two separate living units with distinct entrances and amenities (kitchens and bathrooms). Here, it is evident that this property contains more than one dwelling.

– Example 2: A large house with a basement that has been converted into a studio flat with its own kitchen and bathroom. All features indicate split living arrangements, suggesting this may be counted as two dwellings.

– Example 3: A property with multiple rooms but no separate cooking or bathing facilities in some areas. A subjective view might suggest multiple dwellings based on the number of bedrooms, but as they lack essential facilities, they may not qualify as separate dwellings.

Importance of context in Interpretation

When assessing any property for the number of dwellings, context is vital. Here are some factors that provide context:

– Local Housing Market: Consider how other properties in the area are classified and used. If most properties are recognized as multi-dwellings, it may sway the interpretation of your property.

– Community Needs: Reflect on the needs of the community around the property. If there is a demand for multiple rental units, it may reflect that the property could be viewed as having multiple dwellings depending on its layout and facilities.

– Intended Use: How the property is being marketed and used can influence its classification. If the owner is renting out individual rooms while still being considered a single dwelling, this ambiguity requires a closer look.

Conclusion and Recommendations

While this section provides insight into how HMRC assesses the number of dwellings within a property, it is always advisable to consult a tax professional or legal advisor when in doubt. Having expert guidance can help protect your interests and ensure that you are compliant with current regulations.

However, understanding these basic principles will prepare you to engage more effectively in discussions around property assessments and allow you to make informed decisions regarding any property transactions.

For further details, refer to SDLTM00415 – Scope: what is chargeable: land transactions: Residential Property–How many Dwellings?.

Useful article? You may find it helpful to read the original guidance here: HMRC SDLT: SDLTM00415 – Scope: what is chargeable: land transactions: Residential Property–How many Dwellings? Forming a Balanced Judgement

View all HMRC SDLT Guidance Pages Here