HMRC SDLT: SDLTM01300 – Scope: What is chargeable: Options and rights of pre-emption FA03/S46

Scope: Chargeable Options and Rights of Pre-emption

This section of the HMRC internal manual outlines the principles and concepts related to chargeable options and rights of pre-emption under FA03/S46. It provides guidance on what constitutes a chargeable interest and the implications for tax purposes.

  • Defines chargeable options and rights of pre-emption.
  • Explains the tax implications of these interests.
  • Clarifies the scope of FA03/S46 regarding chargeable interests.
  • Offers guidance for HMRC staff on handling related cases.

Options and Rights of Pre-emption: Understanding SDLT Implications

Introduction to Options and Pre-emption Rights

An option to buy land gives a potential buyer the right, for a fee, to purchase property up until a specific date. This option is a legally binding commitment made by the landowner.

Pre-emption rights, often called rights of first refusal, allow a buyer the first opportunity to purchase the property before the landowner can sell it to anyone else. Like options, these rights are granted in exchange for a fee and limit the landowner’s ability to engage in a sale with other buyers.

It is important to note:

– A reservation deposit or similar payment does not qualify as an option or a pre-emption right.
– Both options and pre-emption rights are considered interests in land.
– However, neither of these qualifies as a “major interest” in land.

Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) and Its Applicability

Acquiring an option or a pre-emption right is considered a land transaction, which means it may be subject to Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT). This tax can also apply to the sale, variation, or surrender of either option or pre-emption rights.

According to the Financial Act 2003 (FA03/S55(1) & (4) and FA03/S116(1)), the classification of the option or pre-emption right as residential, mixed-use, or non-residential aligns with the type of property linked to the option or right.

When someone exercises an option or right of pre-emption, it leads to another land transaction that is also subject to SDLT. While this is considered its own separate transaction, it is generally related to the prior grant of the option or right. For further insight, refer to examples at SDLTM01300A and SDLM01300B.

When the Transactions are Distinct

In some cases, exercising the option may not be associated with the grant. For example, if the option has been passed on to another person who was not involved with or connected to the original agreement, the exercise of the option is considered separate from the granting of the original option.

Understanding the Charge to SDLT

Options fall under the SDLT charge even if the grantor can fulfil their obligations in different ways. This could include entering a land transaction or simply paying a fee.

When acquiring an option or pre-emption right, SDLT is due based on the option price at the applicable rates for the type of land involved. There are specific considerations when the option is exercised:

1. If the option is exercised and is linked to the original grant:
– SDLT is calculated on:
– The option acquisition value, proportionate to the total SDLT charge based on the entire transaction amount, including the option price assessed at the time of the grant.
– Additionally:
– SDLT is also calculated on the value when exercising the option, using the rates applicable at that time, considering both the total transaction value and the option price.
– Any SDLT amount paid upon acquiring the option will factor into the total tax calculation at this stage.

Examples to Clarify SDLT Calculations

To better understand how these calculations work, let’s look at a couple of examples. Note that specific figures and scenarios from the original guidance are paraphrased or reshaped for clarity.

Example 1: Acquisition of an Option

– A landowner grants an option to a buyer for a fee of £10,000 to purchase land valued at £200,000.
– At the time of granting, the SDLT is calculated on £10,000. Let’s assume the applicable SDLT rate is 1%.
– Therefore, the buyer will initially pay £100 in SDLT when acquiring the option.

If the buyer later decides to exercise the option and purchases the land, the consideration would include:
– The option price of £10,000 plus the property value of £200,000.
– The SDLT due on the total value at the time of exercise will then factor in the £10,000 previously paid.

Example 2: Exercising a Pre-emption Right

– A buyer may have a pre-emption right granted for a fee of £5,000, with a property’s market value at £250,000.
– When the property owner decides to sell, they must first offer it to the holder of the pre-emption right.
– If the buyer pays £250,000 to exercise the pre-emption, the SDLT will now apply to this total consideration. In this case, the effective SDLT is calculated based on the current rates that apply at the time of this sale.

Notification Requirements for SDLT

The granting of an option is seen as the acquisition of a chargeable interest in land but does not count as a major interest; consequently, it does not require notification unless SDLT is due.

However, it is essential to remember that when an option is exercised, the link between the grant and its exercise often triggers a notification requirement due to the Financial Act provisions (FA03/S81A). If SDLT arises from this transaction, either from the grant or the exercising of the option, then a return must be filed.

Final Thoughts on SDLT Related to Options and Pre-emption Rights

Understanding how options and pre-emption rights impact SDLT is crucial for both buyers and sellers in property transactions. By recognising the relationship between the grant and the exercise of these rights, and how SDLT is calculated on them, parties can ensure compliance with tax obligations.

It’s always a good idea to consult a tax professional or legal expert to navigate the complexities of property transactions and ensure all aspects of SDLT are accurately addressed.

Useful article? You may find it helpful to read the original guidance here: HMRC SDLT: SDLTM01300 – Scope: What is chargeable: Options and rights of pre-emption FA03/S46

Search Land Tax Advice with Google Site Search

I am here to help. I offer free expert advice to help you understand your land tax obligations, rights, and entitlements.

Our fees come from no-win, no-fee stamp duty claims, and advice to lower your land tax liability under some circumstances.

Contact me below

Speak with Nick Garner

To discuss your stamp duty rebate case
call today:
0204 577 3323

Written by Land Tax Expert Nick Garner.
See free excerpts here.