HMRC SDLT: SDLTM04045 – Scope: How much is chargeable: Non-cash consideration: Nil-rate band discretionary trusts

Principles and Concepts of Nil-rate Band Discretionary Trusts

This section of the HMRC internal manual explains the scope and chargeability of non-cash considerations within nil-rate band discretionary trusts. It covers the following key principles and concepts:

  • Definition and purpose of nil-rate band discretionary trusts.
  • How non-cash considerations are evaluated within these trusts.
  • Tax implications and chargeability criteria for trustees.
  • Guidelines for calculating the chargeable amount under specific circumstances.
  • Examples illustrating the application of these rules.

Nil-Rate Band Discretionary Trusts and Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT)

A nil-rate band discretionary trust is often created through the Will of a deceased person. This type of trust allows some assets to be passed on to beneficiaries without incurring inheritance tax, as long as they fall below a specified value known as the nil-rate band.

How a Nil-Rate Band Discretionary Trust Works

  • The trust typically involves a cash legacy that does not exceed the nil-rate band for inheritance tax.
  • This cash legacy is managed by trustees who hold it for a group of chosen beneficiaries, known as a “specified class of beneficiaries.”
  • Usually, the remaining assets, including the family home, will go to the deceased’s surviving spouse or civil partner. In some cases, they may go to the trustees who are responsible for distributing the estate.

When the personal representatives (the individuals assigned to handle the estate) pay the cash legacy to the trustees as per the Will, there is no issue with Stamp Duty Land Tax. However, complications can arise when this payment is made in a different way, particularly related to property transfers.

Property Transfers and SDLT

If the personal representatives satisfy the cash legacy by transferring property—such as the family home—to the surviving spouse, civil partner, or to other appointed trustees, a Stamp Duty Land Tax liability may occur. Here’s how that works:

  • A land transaction occurs whenever there is a transfer of property ownership, even if it’s done to fulfill a Will.
  • The main question is whether the recipient (transferee) provides any chargeable consideration in exchange for the land.
  • Typically, a beneficiary may not provide chargeable consideration when receiving land through a Will, but this can change in cases involving a nil-rate band discretionary trust.

Examples of Transactions and SDLT Implications

Here are the common situations where chargeable considerations may arise:

1. Promise to Pay by Surviving Spouse or Civil Partner:

  • The trustees may accept a promise from the surviving spouse or civil partner to pay the cash legacy.
  • In return for this promise, property is transferred to them.
  • This promise counts as chargeable consideration for SDLT purposes.

2. Promise to Pay by Personal Representatives:

  • The trustees might accept a promise from the personal representatives to make the cash payment.
  • Property is then transferred to the surviving spouse or civil partner when they accept liability for this promise.
  • The individual’s acceptance of liability becomes chargeable consideration, with the chargeable amount being what was promised (but not exceeding the property’s market value).

3. Charging the Property:

  • If the surviving spouse or civil partner takes on a charge against the property for the payment of the cash legacy, and the trustees agree to this, it constitutes chargeable consideration.
  • This effectively means that the charge is seen as money’s worth for SDLT purposes.

4. Charge by Personal Representatives:

  • In some cases, personal representatives might charge the land to secure payment of the cash legacy.
  • If both the trustees and the personal representatives agree that the trustees will not enforce payment against the land’s current owner, this transaction can still take place without triggering SDLT, provided there’s no change in the obligations regarding the charged amount.

Deeds of Variation and Land Transactions

A deed of variation allows beneficiaries to change a Will after the person’s death. This can lead to land transactions if it changes who benefits from the land. For instance, beneficiaries could agree to settle land in a trust through a deed of variation.

However, just putting a charge on a property does not automatically mean a land transaction has occurred. There are specific rules under FA03/SCH3/PARA4 that might allow certain deeds of variation to be exempt from SDLT if they meet particular criteria.

Other Tax Considerations

This information primarily focuses on SDLT and does not address any other taxes or the responsibilities of trustees and personal representatives. If you are involved with a nil-rate band discretionary trust, seeking professional legal advice may be a good idea to ensure all responsibilities and duties are correctly understood and followed.

Search Land Tax Advice with Google Site Search

I am here to help. I offer free expert advice to help you understand your land tax obligations, rights, and entitlements.

Our fees come from no-win, no-fee stamp duty claims, and advice to lower your land tax liability under some circumstances.

Contact me below

Speak with Nick Garner

To discuss your stamp duty rebate case
call today:
0204 577 3323

Written by Land Tax Expert Nick Garner.
See free excerpts here.