HMRC SDLT: SDLTM05040A – Scope: How much is chargeable: Contingent, uncertain or unascertained consideration: Adjustments under FA03/S80: General: Example

Principles and Concepts of Chargeable Consideration

This section of the HMRC internal manual provides guidance on determining the chargeable amount for contingent, uncertain, or unascertained consideration under FA03/S80. It includes an example to illustrate the application of these principles.

  • Explains the scope of chargeable consideration.
  • Details adjustments under FA03/S80.
  • Provides an example for practical understanding.
  • Focuses on contingent, uncertain, or unascertained considerations.

Understanding Chargeable Consideration for Stamp Duty Land Tax

Introduction to Chargeable Consideration

When you buy property in the UK, you may have to pay Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT). This tax is calculated based on the amount you pay for the property, known as ‘chargeable consideration.’ It is important to determine the exact amount that is chargeable to ensure correct payment of this tax.

What is Chargeable Consideration?

Chargeable consideration includes any money or value you transfer when you buy property. This can be straightforward, like a fixed purchase price, but can also include other amounts that may depend on certain conditions.

Fixed vs. Contingent Consideration

– Fixed consideration is a set amount that both parties agree upon before the sale.
– Contingent consideration is an amount that you will only pay if specific conditions are met. For example, if you agree to pay an additional amount only if you get planning permission to develop the property.

Example of Chargeable Consideration

Let’s look at an example involving two companies, P Ltd and V Ltd.

– The Deal: P Ltd signs a contract with V Ltd to buy a piece of land.
– Purchase Price: The agreed price is £10 million.
– Contingent Payment: P Ltd will also pay an extra £5 million if it can successfully obtain planning permission to build an industrial park on this land within the next five years.

In this scenario, the total chargeable consideration for the purpose of SDLT is £15 million (£10 million + £5 million).

Payment of Stamp Duty Land Tax

In the example above, P Ltd does not apply to defer payment of the SDLT. Therefore, they pay the tax based on the total consideration of £15 million upfront.

What Happens If Conditions Are Not Met?

Suppose that after five years, P Ltd applies for planning permission but is unsuccessful. In this case, the additional payment of £5 million will not be required.

However, P Ltd can claim for a repayment of the SDLT that corresponds to that £5 million. This means that while they paid SDLT on the assumption that they would pay £15 million, they can recoup the tax on the amount that they eventually did not pay.

Interest on Repayment Claims

When P Ltd makes a claim to get back the SDLT for the £5 million, the HMRC will calculate if any interest is due on that amount. This means that P Ltd could receive extra money back because they paid tax on an amount they never actually had to spend.

Understanding the Rules and Adjustments

Certain rules apply when making claims for repayments or adjustments related to SDLT. Here are some key points to remember:

– Section 90 of FA03: This section contains provisions relating to the deferral of SDLT payment. P Ltd didn’t apply for this, which means they paid SDLT on the total upfront amount.
– Section 80: This section relates to making adjustments and explains how much SDLT you should pay when circumstances change.

Let’s clarify these principles using our example:

– P Ltd expected to pay £15 million total, which triggered SDLT on this amount.
– After five years, when they find out they do not need to pay the additional £5 million, they can claim back SDLT that was based on this unfulfilled condition.

Making a Claim for Repayment of SDLT

To reclaim SDLT, P Ltd should follow these steps:

1. Preparing Documentation: Gather all the necessary documents showing the original payment and the conditions that were not met.
2. Submitting the Claim: Present the claim to HMRC, clearly stating the reasons for the repayment.
3. Await HMRC’s Decision: After submitting, P Ltd must wait for HMRC to process their claim.

This process is essential for getting back the tax paid on the amount that is not actually owed.

When to Seek Professional Advice

Understanding SDLT and the complexities of chargeable consideration can be challenging. Here are some situations when you might consider seeking professional guidance:

– If your deal involves multiple layers of payments or conditions.
– When you are unsure about how the rules apply to your specific situation.
– If there is a likelihood of needing to reclaim SDLT in the future, especially in contingent cases.

A solicitor or tax advisor with experience in property transactions can help ensure compliance with tax rules and optimize your SDLT liability.

Conclusion

Stamp Duty Land Tax can seem complicated, especially when dealing with contingent considerations. Clarity about what constitutes chargeable consideration, as well as the rules for repayment, will help ensure that you understand your obligations and rights.

For further information, including specific cases or provisions, you can visit the official HMRC guidance pages related to SDLT. For additional resources, refer to SDLTM0000.

Search Land Tax Advice with Google Site Search

I am here to help. I offer free expert advice to help you understand your land tax obligations, rights, and entitlements.

Our fees come from no-win, no-fee stamp duty claims, and advice to lower your land tax liability under some circumstances.

Contact me below

Speak with Nick Garner

To discuss your stamp duty rebate case
call today:
0204 577 3323

Written by Land Tax Expert Nick Garner.
See free excerpts here.