HMRC SDLT: SDLTM07850 – Scope: When is Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) chargeable: Contracts and substantial performance: What is substantial performance FA03/S44(5)

Principles of Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) Chargeability

This section of the HMRC internal manual discusses the chargeability of Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) under specific conditions. It focuses on the concept of ‘substantial performance’ as outlined in FA03/S44(5).

  • Explains when SDLT becomes chargeable on property transactions.
  • Details the criteria for ‘substantial performance’ of contracts.
  • Provides guidance on interpreting FA03/S44(5) within property law.
  • Aims to clarify tax obligations for property buyers and sellers.

Understanding Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) and Substantial Performance

Introduction to Substantial Performance

When it comes to Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT), an important concept is ‘substantial performance.’ This refers to the point at which a contract for a property is considered to have been largely fulfilled. This is crucial because it influences when the SDLT becomes payable.

In simple terms, a contract is deemed *substantially performed* when two key conditions are met:

  • The purchaser has taken possession of almost all of the property involved in the contract. To learn more about this aspect, you can check SDLTM07900.
  • A significant portion of the payment has been made or provided. For more information on payment aspects, refer to SDLTM07950.

Conditions for Substantial Performance

To determine whether a contract has been substantially performed, we need to assess both conditions mentioned:

1. Possession of the Property

The first condition focuses on the possession of the property. If the purchaser takes over nearly all of the property involved in the contract, this indicates substantial performance. Here’s a clearer look at this aspect:

– If you purchased a house and moved in, this fulfills the condition of taking possession.
– If you got the keys to a flat but can’t access the entire property, then it may not count as substantial possession.

2. Payment Consideration

The second condition looks at the payments made towards the contract. A substantial amount needs to be paid or provided to count as substantial performance. Consider these scenarios:

– If you’re buying a property for £300,000 and have paid £290,000, this is likely substantial.
– Conversely, if you have only paid £50,000 of a £300,000 property, it would not meet this condition.

Fact-Based Determination

Whether a contract has been substantially performed is ultimately a matter of fact. This means that each situation is unique and must be assessed on its own merits. No standard percentage or specific amount can be universally applied.

For example:

– For someone buying an office building, taking over the majority of the offices and paying a substantial part of the purchase price might be considered substantial performance.
– On the other hand, if a buyer only has access to a small section of a larger commercial building, the contract may not be seen as substantially performed, even if a significant payment has been made.

Importance of Substantial Performance in SDLT

Why does substantial performance matter? It affects when the SDLT has to be paid. SDLT is due when a contract is considered substantially performed, not necessarily when the full payment is made or the transaction is officially recorded.

This concept is vital for both buyers and sellers of property, as it establishes a timeline for when the tax liability begins. Here’s how it breaks down:

– If you take possession of a property and make substantial payments, you may trigger SDLT at that time.
– If substantial performance is not achieved, you may not need to pay SDLT immediately.

Examples of SDLT and Substantial Performance Scenarios

Understanding practical examples can help clarify how substantial performance works in relation to SDLT:

Example 1: Purchasing a Residential Property

Imagine a buyer agrees to purchase a flat. They make a total payment of £250,000 and take possession of the entire flat. Since they have access to the whole property and made a significant payment, this contract is likely to be considered substantially performed. Therefore, the buyer would need to pay SDLT at this point.

Example 2: Buying a Commercial Property

Consider a scenario where a buyer is purchasing a commercial building for £1,000,000. The buyer has only made a deposit of £100,000 and has not yet occupied the majority of the building. In this situation, neither condition of substantial performance is met, so the buyer does not have to pay SDLT yet.

Example 3: Part Occupancy Scenario

A buyer of an industrial unit has gained access to most of the property but not a small adjoining warehouse. They have paid 80% of the total price. The buyer may argue that since they are in possession of a significant part of the property and have made a substantial payment, this should count as substantial performance. However, because of not occupying the entire space, the tax implications may be complex and require further examination.

Considerations for Buyers and Sellers

Buyers and sellers should be mindful of how substantial performance affects SDLT liability. Here are some key considerations:

  • Keep clear records of payments made. This will help determine your SDLT position at different points in the transaction.
  • Understand your occupancy rights with regard to the property. If you’re not fully in control, you may need more clarity on your SDLT obligations.
  • Consider seeking legal advice if your transaction is complex or if you’re unsure about how substantial performance applies to your situation.

Final Thoughts on SDLT and Substantial Performance

Navigating the rules around SDLT and substantial performance can be tricky. The determining factors revolve around possession and payment, but ultimately, each situation must be evaluated individually. Keeping a close eye on these factors can help ensure compliance and prevent any unexpected tax liabilities from arising.

Remember, understanding when SDLT is due is essential for all property transactions. Always seek to confirm your obligations and consider professional advice when faced with uncertainties.

Search Land Tax Advice with Google Site Search

I am here to help. I offer free expert advice to help you understand your land tax obligations, rights, and entitlements.

Our fees come from no-win, no-fee stamp duty claims, and advice to lower your land tax liability under some circumstances.

Contact me below

Speak with Nick Garner

To discuss your stamp duty rebate case
call today:
0204 577 3323

Written by Land Tax Expert Nick Garner.
See free excerpts here.