HMRC SDLT: SDLTM14100 – Term of a lease: Holding over

Principles and Concepts of Lease Holding Over

This section of the HMRC internal manual discusses the concept of ‘holding over’ in the context of lease agreements. It provides guidance on the implications when a tenant remains in a property after the lease term has expired.

• Explains the legal framework surrounding holding over.
• Details the rights and responsibilities of both landlords and tenants.
• Outlines potential tax implications for holding over.
• Provides examples of common scenarios and their outcomes.

SDLTM14100 – Term of a Lease: Holding Over

This article explains the concept of holding over in relation to lease terms. Holding over refers to what happens when a lease expires but the tenant continues to stay in the property with the landlord’s consent. This situation may lead to different legal implications for both the tenant and the landlord.

What is Holding Over?

Holding over occurs when a tenant remains in the property after their lease has officially ended. This may happen with or without a new lease agreement in place. The key points to understand are:

• The tenant stays in the property after the lease has expired.
• The landlord has agreed to the tenant remaining in the property.
• This status may affect rent and rights for both parties.

Types of Holding Over

There are two main types of holding over:

1. Tenancy at Sufferance

This occurs when a tenant stays in the property without any permission from the landlord. The tenant is essentially occupying the property unlawfully. However, the landlord has the right to remove the tenant if they choose to do so.

2. Tenancy at Will

This type of holding over happens when the landlord allows the tenant to stay in the property after the lease expires. The agreement is often informal and can be terminated by either the tenant or landlord without notice. Important aspects to note include:

• Each party can end the agreement quickly.
• The terms of any tenancy at will can usually be set informally.

Legal Implications of Holding Over

When a lease expires and the tenant holds over, several legal aspects come into play:

1. Continuing Obligations

When a tenant holds over, they may still be bound by certain obligations from the original lease. For example:

• The tenant is typically required to continue paying rent.
• Other obligations, such as maintenance and utilities, may also still apply.

2. New Terms

If the landlord agrees to the tenant holding over, they may establish new terms for the continued occupation. This may include:

• A change in rent amount.
• New rules or responsibilities for both parties.

3. Eviction Procedures

In situations where holding over becomes a problem, either party can choose to end the arrangement. The landlord may need to follow specific legal processes to evict the tenant, especially if the tenant is occupying the property against the landlord’s wishes.

Rent During Holding Over

When a tenant holds over, rent comes into play:

• The tenant may be required to pay rent at the same rate as the expired lease.
• If new terms have been established, the landlord can require a different amount.

Practical Examples of Holding Over

To illustrate the concept further, consider these scenarios:

Example 1: Tenancy at Sufferance

Imagine a tenant named Sarah, whose lease ends on 30th June. Sarah does not leave the property on that date, and the landlord has not agreed to her staying. Sarah is now considered a tenant at sufferance. The landlord can ask her to leave the property at any time.

Example 2: Tenancy at Will

Now, think about another tenant, John, whose lease also ends on 30th June. Unlike Sarah, John discusses his situation with the landlord and they agree that he can remain in the property on a month-to-month basis while they sort out the terms of a new lease. John now has a tenancy at will, meaning he can leave whenever he wants, and the landlord can also ask him to leave with short notice.

Notice Periods in Holding Over

The notice period may vary depending on the agreement between the landlord and tenant:

• If both parties are informal about the arrangement, usually a simple discussion may suffice.
• If a more formal tenancy at will is established, the notice period should be clearly outlined.

Considerations for Landlords

Landlords should think carefully before allowing a tenant to hold over, as this can lead to complications. Consider these points:

• Maintaining clear communication with the tenant about the status of their tenancy is essential.
• Be aware of the rights the tenant has when holding over, as this may require legal guidance.
• Take care to document any agreements made regarding rent or conditions during the holding over period.

Considerations for Tenants

As a tenant, if you find yourself holding over, keep the following in mind:

• Understand your obligations from the original lease, especially concerning rent payments.
• Communicate openly with your landlord about your plans or concerns.
• Seek legal advice if you’re unsure about your rights or situation.

Impact of Holding Over on Lease Renewal

Holding over can also impact any newer agreements:

• It might complicate negotiations for a new lease, as the landlord may feel uncertain about the tenant’s reliability.
• A tenant holding over may have less negotiating power when it comes to rent or lease terms.

Documenting Holding Over Arrangements

Keeping records during any holding over period is important for both landlords and tenants. Here’s what should be documented:

• Any agreement about rent or new terms must be in writing.
• Date when the tenants began holding over should be noted.
• Communications with the landlord or tenant about holding over should be documented.

Resources for Landlords and Tenants

Both landlords and tenants should familiarize themselves with their rights and responsibilities when it comes to holding over. Helpful resources include:

• Official government websites for guidance on tenancies and leases.
• Legal advice services that can provide tailored support.
• Local housing charities that may offer information or assistance.

Final Thoughts

Understanding the implications of holding over is vital for both landlords and tenants. By knowing your rights and responsibilities, you can navigate this situation more effectively.

For a detailed look at specific terms associated with holding over, check out relevant resources: SDLTM0000.

Useful article? You may find it helpful to read the original guidance here: HMRC SDLT: SDLTM14100 – Term of a lease: Holding over

View all HMRC SDLT Guidance Pages Here