Read the original guidance here:
HMRC SDLT: Understanding Group Tax Relief and Recovery Under Paragraph 3 Clawback Rules

Understanding SDLTM23018 – Reliefs: Group Tax Bulletin Article

This article discusses important aspects of the reliefs and recovery under the Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) regulations related to group companies, particularly focusing on the distinction between different paragraphs outlined in the legislation.

Key Concepts

• Paragraph 2 vs. Paragraph 3: These paragraphs refer to different conditions under which reliefs may be granted or recovered. It is essential to understand that the rules in Paragraph 3 operate independently of those in Paragraph 2.
• Enquiries into Claims: When HMRC investigates a claim for relief, the main question is whether the claim complies with the statutory requirements, rather than whether the arrangements could potentially lead to recovery.

The Role of Paragraph 3

Paragraph 3 outlines rules about recovering relief that has been given to companies within a group. Here are some key points:

• Recovery Period: There is a specific recovery period of three years for group companies. Relief can be challenged if a member of the group leaves during this time.
• Return Requirement: According to paragraph 3(1)(a)(ii), a return must be submitted if a company stops being part of the same group within three years of the transaction.

Details on the Recovery Period

When a company is part of a group and moves out of the group during the specified three-year recovery period, certain steps must be followed:

• Filing a Return: The company must file a return to indicate the withdrawal of relief. This is outlined in section 81 of the Finance Act 2003.
• Determining Arrangements: Paragraph 3(1)(a)(ii) stipulates that relief will be retrieved if arrangements for the transfer of the company outside the group were made before this three-year period ended.

Understanding Arrangements

The term ‘arrangements’ is defined in both Paragraph 2 and 3, indicating a clear concept that applies to various sections of the legislation:

• Definition Consistency: The definition of arrangements remains consistent in both paragraphs, which allows for a clear understanding of what constitutes an arrangement.

Actions Following a Transfer Outside the Group

When a company moves outside the group, it is vital for the companies involved to assess their obligations:

• Post-Transfer Considerations: If the transfer occurs after the three-year period, companies should still evaluate whether their actions were in accordance with any arrangements made during the recovery period.
• Investigation Requirements: To make a proper assessment, detailed consideration of all circumstances surrounding the transfer is necessary.

HM Revenue & Customs Investigation Process

HMRC does not automatically assume there were arrangements made during the three-year period just because a transfer happens soon after it ends:

• Fact-Based Determination: HMRC will examine the specific facts of each case to determine if recovery should take place. There must be strong evidence indicating that arrangements for the transfer existed during the recovery period.

Practical Example

Consider two companies within the same group, Company A and Company B:

• Company A has been benefiting from group relief since it acquired a property.
• Say Company B is planned to be transferred out of the group a few months after the three-year recovery period ends.
• If the transfer plan was made during the three-year period, Company A must file a return to reclaim the relief it received.
• However, if no arrangements were made during that time, Company A may not be required to file a return.

This example illustrates how vital timing and proper assessment are in deciding whether to file a return after a company leaves the group.

Final Notes on Compliance

• Maintaining Records: Companies should keep comprehensive records of any arrangements made, as this will support their position in any future enquiries.
• Consultation is Key: When in doubt, it is advisable for companies to consult tax professionals to ensure all regulatory requirements are met and that reliefs are correctly claimed or recovered.

By understanding the distinctions between Paragraph 2 and Paragraph 3, companies can better navigate the complexities of group relief and compliance with SDLT regulations.