HMRC SDLT: Group Relief Withdrawal: B Ltd Leaves Group, Stamp Duty Land Tax Reassessed

Group Relief and Stamp Duty Land Tax

This summary explains the implications of group relief withdrawal in the context of stamp duty land tax when a company leaves a group within three years of a property transaction. It uses the example of A Ltd and B Ltd, where B Ltd exits the group, leading to the withdrawal of previously claimed group relief.

• A Ltd and B Ltd form a group for stamp duty land tax purposes, with A Ltd transferring land to B Ltd without consideration.
• B Ltd claims group relief on the transfer, but later grants a lease to an unrelated third party.
• A Ltd sells B Ltd’s shares to an unconnected third party, causing B Ltd to leave the group within three years.
• Due to B Ltd’s exit from the group, the previously claimed group relief is withdrawn as no exceptions apply.
• The stamp duty land tax is recalculated based on the market value of the chargeable interest at the time of the original transaction.
• The tax payable is adjusted according to the proportion of the original transaction’s market value now held by B Ltd.

“`

Relief for Group, Reconstruction or Acquisition: SDLTM23090E

This section explains the situation where group relief is withdrawn when a purchaser stops being part of the same group as the seller within three years of a transaction involving stamp duty land tax. It also details how to calculate the stamp duty land tax under these circumstances.

Key Concepts

• Group Relief: This is a tax relief that allows companies within a group to transfer assets without paying stamp duty land tax. For group relief to apply, both the purchaser and the vendor must be members of the same group at the time of the transaction.
• Chargeable Interest: This term refers to the rights in a property that are subject to stamp duty land tax. It can include freehold or leasehold interests, among other rights.
• Relevant Transaction: This is the specific transaction taking place, which, in this context, is the transfer of a property from one company to another.
• Market Value: This is the estimated worth of the property at the time of the relevant transaction. It is essential for calculating the stamp duty land tax.

Example Scenario

To illustrate how group relief works, consider this example involving two companies:

• A Ltd: This is the company selling the property (the vendor).
• B Ltd: This company is purchasing the property and is owned entirely by A Ltd.

Since A Ltd fully owns B Ltd, these two companies form a group for stamp duty land tax purposes.

The Relevant Transaction

On 25 June 2004, A Ltd transfers the freehold interest of a parcel of land to B Ltd without any payment (no consideration). The market value of the land at this time is £1,000,000. B Ltd then claims group relief for this transfer.

Subsequent Transactions

Later in the timeline:

• On 19 October 2004, B Ltd grants a lease to an unrelated third party, receiving market value for this lease.
• On 7 July 2006, A Ltd sells its shares in B Ltd to an unrelated third party. On this date, the market value of the freehold reversionary interest and the right to receive rent is £900,000. With this sale, B Ltd ceases to be part of the group that includes A Ltd.

Three-Year Rule

According to the rules, group relief can be withdrawn if the purchaser (B Ltd) leaves the group within three years of the relevant transaction, which in this case would be calculated up to 24 June 2007. Since B Ltd left the group on 7 July 2006, a little over two years after the property transfer, group relief is no longer applicable, because no special exceptions apply.

Stamp Duty Land Tax Calculation

Now that group relief is withdrawn, we need to determine the stamp duty land tax that B Ltd must pay on the transferred property. The tax is based on the current ownership status of B Ltd, which now holds the freehold reversionary interest instead of the freehold interest that was transferred between the two companies.

• The stamp duty land tax owed is calculated based on the original transaction’s market value and the chargeable interest that B Ltd holds now.

Determining the Current Market Value

To ascertain the stamp duty land tax payable:

1. Determine the market value of the chargeable interest B Ltd currently holds. If this value is £850,000 at the time of the original transaction on 25 June 2004, proceed to the next step.

2. Calculate the amount of stamp duty land tax based on the original market value of the relevant transaction, which was £1,000,000 on 25 June 2004.

3. The tax to be paid will then be adjusted using the proportion of the new market value to the original market value. This is expressed as:

1. Current Market Value Held (£850,000)
2. Divided by Original Transaction Market Value (£1,000,000)

4. Thus, the stamp duty land tax calculation would reflect this proportion. The actual tax owed will depend on the specific stamp duty land tax rates applicable at that time.

This situation outlines the critical aspects of the group relief process concerning stamp duty land tax, especially how withdrawal of that relief affects tax liability when a purchaser leaves a group within the three-year period following a relevant transaction.

Useful article? You may find it helpful to read the original guidance here: HMRC SDLT: Group Relief Withdrawal: B Ltd Leaves Group, Stamp Duty Land Tax Reassessed

View all HMRC SDLT Guidance Pages Here