HMRC SDLT: SDLTM09230 – The comparison test: Section 75A (1)(c)

Principles and Concepts of SDLTM09230 – The Comparison Test

This section of the HMRC internal manual explains the comparison test under Section 75A (1)(c). It provides guidance on how to apply the test to determine tax liabilities. The principles and concepts include:

• Understanding the purpose of the comparison test in tax assessments.
• Identifying transactions that may be subject to the test.
• Applying the test to evaluate potential tax avoidance.
• Ensuring compliance with HMRC regulations and guidelines.

Understanding the Comparison Test: Section 75A (1)(c)

Introduction to SDLT and Notional Land Transactions

When dealing with Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) in real estate transactions, it’s important to understand how to assess the tax obligations for notional land transactions.

A notional land transaction occurs when there is a simulated transfer of land, usually when multiple transactions are involved in a broader scheme. In these cases, we must calculate SDLT for the notional transaction and also the SDLT for each of the actual transactions involved in the scheme.

Calculating SDLT for Notional Transactions

To determine the SDLT payable for the notional land transaction between two parties, which we can refer to as V (the vendor) and P (the purchaser), follow these key steps:

1. Calculate the Consideration: The first step is to work out the total consideration, which means the amount that is being paid or transferred in the notional land transaction.

2. Determine SDLT for the Notional Transaction: Once you have the consideration figure, calculate the SDLT that will be due based on that amount.

3. Compare SDLT Amounts: After calculating the SDLT for the notional transaction, you should compare it to the SDLT amounts that would be due on each of the transactions in the scheme involving land.

Steps in Detail

Let’s break down the comparison process for better understanding.

Step 1: Calculate Consideration

The consideration is essentially what V receives from P for the land. This figure should be the total value of the property transferred, including any additional payments or benefits received as part of the transaction.

Step 2: Calculate SDLT on the Notional Transaction

Next, apply the appropriate SDLT rates to the calculated consideration. These rates might vary depending on the value of the consideration and the type of transaction. You can find SDLT rates on the official government website or similar authoritative sources.

Step 3: Calculate SDLT for Scheme Transactions

Now, you need to sum up the SDLT from all other transactions in the scheme involving land. Each of these transactions should be assessed individually as well, using the same SDLT rates based on their respective considerations.

Checking the Third Condition of Section 75A

Section 75A outlines the conditions under which a notional land transaction is recognised. The third condition focuses on the relationship between the SDLT amounts calculated.

– If the SDLT for the notional land transaction is greater than the sum of SDLT amounts for all scheme transactions, then this condition is met, and you have a notional land transaction.

– If the SDLT for the notional transaction is equal to or less than the SDLT from the summed scheme transactions, the third condition is not met. As a result, there will be no notional land transaction recognised under Section 75A.

Example of Comparison Test Application

Let’s look at a hypothetical example for clarity.

Scenario:

– V sells a piece of land to P for a consideration of £500,000.
– The SDLT on this amount is calculated at 5%.

Now, we’ll assume V is also involved in other transactions in the same scheme, as below:

– Transaction 1: Sale of an additional plot valued at £200,000 with SDLT due of 1%.
– Transaction 2: Additional assets included in another scheme valued at £300,000, yielding an SDLT of 3%.

Calculations:

– Notional Transaction:
– Consideration = £500,000
– SDLT = £500,000 * 5% = £25,000

– Scheme Transactions Total SDLT:
– Transaction 1: £200,000 * 1% = £2,000
– Transaction 2: £300,000 * 3% = £9,000
– Total SDLT for scheme = £2,000 + £9,000 = £11,000

Comparison of SDLT Amounts

Now, let’s compare the totals:

– Notional transaction SDLT = £25,000
– Total SDLT for scheme transactions = £11,000

In this case, the notional SDLT (£25,000) is greater than the scheme SDLT (£11,000). Therefore, the third condition of Section 75A is satisfied, confirming the existence of a notional land transaction.

Implications of the Comparison Test

Understanding and correctly applying the comparison test is important for compliance with SDLT regulations. If a notional land transaction is recognised, it has significant implications for how SDLT is assessed and paid.

It ensures that the correct amount of tax is calculated based on the overall economic reality of the transactions involved, rather than just isolated parts.

Potential Issues to Consider

– Complex Schemes: In more complex schemes with multiple land transactions, it may become challenging to keep track of all SDLT amounts due. It is essential to document each transaction, the consideration used, and the SDLT calculations meticulously.

– Errors in Calculations: Any inconsistencies or errors in the SDLT calculations for either the notional transaction or the scheme transactions can lead to issues. Ensure all calculations are double-checked.

– Changes to SDLT Rates: SDLT rates can change; hence it is crucial to stay updated with the latest rates when performing calculations for any property transaction.

Final Thoughts on Section 75A

By understanding the principles surrounding the comparison test under Section 75A, individuals and businesses engaged in property transactions can ensure they meet their tax obligations while correctly interpreting the rules around notional land transactions.

For more detailed information on other related topics or to delve deeper into SDLT calculations, visit segments like SDLTM09230 – The comparison test: Section 75A (1)(c).

By having a clear structure for calculating and comparing SDLT amounts, taxpayers can avoid pitfalls and ensure compliance with the tax regulations effectively.

Useful article? You may find it helpful to read the original guidance here: HMRC SDLT: SDLTM09230 – The comparison test: Section 75A (1)(c)

View all HMRC SDLT Guidance Pages Here