HMRC SDLT: SDLTM10050 – Introduction: definitions: tenancy at will

Tenancy at Will: Definitions and Principles

This section of the HMRC internal manual provides an introduction to the concept of a tenancy at will. It outlines the fundamental principles and definitions associated with this type of tenancy agreement.

• A tenancy at will is a temporary arrangement allowing occupation without a fixed term.
• It can be terminated at any time by either party.
• Such tenancies are often used in transitional situations.
• No formal lease agreement is required for a tenancy at will.

SDLTM10050 – Introduction: Definitions of Tenancy at Will

Definition of Tenancy at Will

A tenancy at will is an informal agreement between a landlord (the owner of the property) and a tenant (the person who occupies the property). This type of tenancy allows the tenant to stay on the land with the owner’s permission. Here are the main characteristics of a tenancy at will:

– The agreement can be either written or verbal.
– The tenant occupies the land without being a servant or agent of the owner.
– Either the landlord or the tenant can end the agreement at any time, no matter the circumstances.

Key Conditions of a Tenancy at Will

A tenancy at will has some important features that set it apart from traditional leases:

– End of Agreement: The tenancy automatically ends if:
– Either the landlord or tenant dies.
– The landlord sells the property.

– No Transfer of Rights: A tenancy at will does not create a formal estate in land. This means that tenants cannot transfer or assign their rights to someone else; they simply have permission to occupy the land while the agreement exists.

Tax Implications

According to the legislation found in FA03/S48(2)(c)(i), a tenancy at will is classified as an exempt interest. This exemption is significant because it places tenancies at will outside the scope of Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT).

Legal Context

Some might find the relationship between tenancies at will and taxes confusing due to references in other legal texts, like FA03/SCH17A/PARAS1(b) and 4(5)(b). Despite some parts of the law suggesting that a tenancy at will could be treated like a lease, it is essential to remember:

– A tenancy at will is classified as a lease.
– It is a specific kind of lease that is recognized as an exempt interest for taxation purposes.

This means that while it falls under the broader category of leases, tenancies at will are treated differently in terms of tax obligations.

Examples of Tenancy at Will

Here are some scenarios that illustrate how a tenancy at will works:

1. Room Rentals:
– Sarah lets her spare room to her friend Tom. They agree that Tom can stay indefinitely as long as Sarah does not mind. They have not signed any formal contract. This is a tenancy at will because either Sarah or Tom can end the arrangement at any time.

2. Commercial Use:
– A small retail shop operates in a unit owned by Emily. Emily tells the shop owner, Jack, that he can use the space while they work out a formal lease. They have not signed anything, meaning Jack has a tenancy at will. If Emily decides to sell the property or tells Jack to leave, he must do so without any notice period.

3. Longer-Term Arrangement:
– In another example, an artist works in a studio owned by a local gallery. The gallery owner allows the artist to use the space, saying they can stay as long as they wish, provided they keep the area tidy. This too is a tenancy at will because it is not formalized, and either party could end the arrangement at any moment.

Advantages and Disadvantages

Understanding the pros and cons of a tenancy at will is essential for both landlords and tenants:

Advantages:

– Flexibility: Both landlords and tenants can end the arrangement easily, which can be beneficial if circumstances change.
– Simplicity: Without the need for formal contracts, setting up a tenancy at will can be quicker and less complex.

Disadvantages:

– Lack of Security: Tenants may find themselves having to leave with little notice, which may be troublesome if they are not prepared for it.
– Limited Rights: Since there are no formal agreements, tenants may have fewer rights to the property. This means they could be evicted without notice.

Legal Considerations

Even though tenancies at will are less formal, they still have legal implications:

– Tenants’ Rights: Even without a formal lease, tenants are entitled to stay on the property as long as both parties agree. However, their rights are far less secure than if they had a formal lease.
– Owner’s Obligations: On the other hand, landlords still have a duty to ensure that the property remains safe and habitable for their tenants.

Conclusion

This overview outlines the main aspects of a tenancy at will, detailing how it operates, its legal context, tax implications, and examples of common scenarios. Understanding tenancies at will can help both landlords and tenants navigate their rights and obligations effectively.

For specific circumstances or legal advice regarding tenancies at will, it’s advisable to consult legal professionals or seek information from reputable sources.

Useful article? You may find it helpful to read the original guidance here: HMRC SDLT: SDLTM10050 – Introduction: definitions: tenancy at will

View all HMRC SDLT Guidance Pages Here