Read the original guidance here:
HMRC SDLT: SDLTM13135 – Calculation of Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT): Rent: Variable or uncertain rent: NPV

Understanding Calculation of Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) for Variable or Uncertain Rent

When determining the Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) for a lease, special rules apply when the rent is not fixed. These rules help calculate the net present value (NPV) of the lease when the rent or part of it is variable, contingent, uncertain, or cannot be precisely determined at the time the lease is granted. Here’s a clearer look at these special rules, focusing on how they apply to the first five years of the lease and what happens in subsequent years.

Special Rules for NPV Calculation

According to FA03/SCH17A/PARA7, special rules help evaluate rent when it changes over the term of the lease. This applies specifically when:

• The lease specifies variable rent due to particular provisions.
• There are fixed increases agreed upon in the lease.
• The rent is contingent, uncertain, or cannot be measured at the time of the lease grant.

It’s important to note that this treatment is different from how increases outside the original lease terms are calculated, which is explained in detail at SDLTM15000.

Rent Calculation for the First Five Years

For the NPV calculation concerning the rent for the first five years of a lease:

• If the amount of rent payable is known at the time the lease is granted, these actual figures are used.
• If the rent is fixed and known, these amounts are included in the calculation.
• If the rent is contingent, uncertain, or unascertainable, specific methods are used to assess the rent for the first five years.

To clarify this point, let’s consider an example: if a lease states that the rent will increase every year by a fixed amount, and you know these amounts when the lease is signed, those figures will be used for NPV. If the lease states that the rent may vary based on market conditions and the exact amount isn’t known, then special rules apply to determine what rent should be considered.

Rent Calculation for Periods After the First Five Years

After the first five years, the calculation approach changes. Here’s how:

• Instead of using the actual rent payable for subsequent years after the initial five, you must replace it with the ‘highest rent’ figure taken from any consecutive twelve-month period during the first five years of the lease.
• This means that you will look at the rent amounts for each year and identify the highest amount recorded during that period.
• If you do not know the actual rent, you may use estimated or assumed figures to arrive at this highest amount.

For instance, if you have a lease where the rent was £5,000 in Year 1, £7,000 in Year 2, £6,500 in Year 3, £8,000 in Year 4, and £7,500 in Year 5, the highest rent for your reference would be £8,000, which occurred in Year 4. This amount will be used for NPV in the years following the initial five years.

Considerations for Rent Changes After Five Years

After the first five years, any changes in rent are generally not considered for NPV calculation. However, there are exceptions:

• Any rent changes that occurred before 17 July 2013 and are classified as an ‘abnormal’ increase might impact the calculation as per FA03/SCH17A/PARA14 and FA03/SCH17A/PARA15.

To qualify as an ‘abnormal’ increase, the change must meet specific criteria established by law. The starting date of the highest rent calculation will be based on the beginning of this twelve-month period, which helps in evaluating whether a rent increase is classified as abnormal.

Changes to Abnormal Rent Provisions

It’s crucial to note that the rules regarding abnormal rent were removed for leases with an effective date on or after 17 July 2013. Therefore:

• If a lease began on or after this date, you would only consider the highest rent from the initial five years without factoring in any abnormal increases that may have occurred.

For leases signed before this date, the abnormal rent rules may still apply, allowing a different NPV calculation approach based on past rent changes.

Final Considerations

Understanding how to calculate SDLT for variable or uncertain rent requires careful attention to the specific rules set out in the law. By applying the defined methods to determine rent for both the first five years and subsequent years, landlords and tenants can adequately navigate their obligations in relation to SDLT.

From accurately assessing the rent for the initial years to identifying the highest amount for the later years, each step is essential for ensuring correct compliance with the taxation process. Always ensure that you keep thorough records for quick reference, especially if conditions around your lease changes over time.