Read the original guidance here:
HMRC SDLT: Understanding First-Time Buyer Relief: Impact of Previous Property Acquisitions by Settlements

Understanding First-Time Buyer Relief Regarding Settlements

This article explains how the rules around first-time buyer relief apply when a purchaser has previously acquired property as a trustee of a settlement. We will go through the main ideas and provide clear examples to help illustrate these points.

Key Principles of First-Time Buyer Relief

First-time buyer relief is a benefit that reduces the amount of stamp duty a person needs to pay when buying their first property. However, specific situations can affect eligibility for this relief, especially concerning previous acquisitions as a trustee.

What is a Settlement?

A settlement is a legal arrangement where property is managed by trustees for the benefit of others. The individuals who benefit from this property are known as beneficiaries. If a beneficiary buys a property in their own right, their previous involvement with the settlement will determine if they can claim relief.

For a detailed explanation of the term ‘settlement,’ you can refer to more information on SDLTM31720.

Eligibility for Relief

– Relief is not denied solely due to a previous acquisition by a settlement.
– If a purchaser is a beneficiary of a settlement but does not hold an interest in the property concerned, they may still qualify for relief.
– However, if the property held in the settlement makes the purchase subject to higher rates of tax, as outlined in paragraph 1 of Schedule 4ZA, relief may not be available.

Examples of First-Time Buyer Relief In Various Scenarios

The following examples provide a clear understanding of how these rules apply in different scenarios involving settlements:

Example 1: Beneficiary and Trustee of a Discretionary Settlement

– Situation: ‘A’ and others acquired a property as trustees of a discretionary settlement. ‘A’ is also a beneficiary of this settlement. Now, ‘A’ is looking to buy a new dwelling in their name for their own use.

– Outcome: Relief is available to ‘A’. It does not matter if they currently occupy the property held in trust or not.

Example 2: Trustee of an Interest in Possession Settlement

– Situation: ‘B’ and others are trustees of an interest in possession settlement. ‘B’ does not possess the interest in possession. Now ‘B’ is purchasing a dwelling in their own name for personal use.

– Outcome: ‘B’ is eligible for relief on this personal acquisition. Previous holdings as a trustee do not block them from claiming relief.

Example 3: Trustees Buying for a Beneficiary

– Situation: ‘C’, ‘D’, and ‘E’ are trustees of an interest in possession settlement. They buy a property to allow the beneficiary, ‘F’, to rent and occupy.

– Outcome: Relief is not applicable because the trustees are regarded as the purchasers. They do not occupy the property as their own or main residence, which limits relief options.

– Now, when ‘F’ decides to purchase a dwelling for their own use, they ask the trustees to rent out the property.

– Further Outcome: Relief is again unavailable to ‘F’ on this acquisition. This is because they are considered to hold an interest in a dwelling under Schedule 4ZA. Thus, the transaction would be seen as a higher rates transaction, preventing relief under Schedule 6ZA paragraph 1(7).

Example 4: Selling Trust Property Before Personal Acquisition

– Situation: Imagine the trust property that was previously rented out is sold instead. After this sale, ‘F’ purchases a dwelling in their own name for personal use.

– Outcome: In this case, relief applies. Since ‘F’ was not treated as the purchaser of the trust property, the higher rates of tax do not affect their new purchase.

Key Takeaways about Higher Rates Transactions

– If a previous acquisition of property affects the nature of the new purchase, it is essential to be aware of higher rates of stamp duty.
– Enough distance between the transactions (like a sale of the trust property) can allow relief to apply to subsequent individual purchases.

When Relief is Denied

It is important to note that relief can be denied if:

– The trustee or beneficiary is treated as holding an interest in a dwelling. This situation can change eligibility for relief based on the property’s status.

– A higher rate transaction is identified under relevant schedules, leaving the purchaser responsible for increased tax rates.

Understanding these rules is vital for ensuring that first-time buyers are informed of their rights and options, especially when dealing with legal structures such as settlements.

Final Thoughts

Navigating the rules around first-time buyer relief in relation to settlements may seem complicated. However, understanding how previous acquisitions as a trustee affect eligibility can help individuals make informed decisions when buying properties. It’s always best to consult with a tax professional or legal advisor to ensure all aspects are considered to optimise any potential relief available.