Read the original guidance here:
HMRC SDLT: SDLTM49350 – Commencement and transitional provisions

SDLTM49350 – Commencement and Transitional Provisions

Introduction to Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT)

Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) is a tax charged on certain land transactions in the UK. It applies when people buy land, generally when a property is purchased. After the law changed on 10 July 2003, all transactions conform to these new rules. However, some issues may arise for transactions that arguably fall outside the scope of SDLT.

Oral Contracts and SDLT

A taxpayer might claim that a land transaction that occurred after the changes to the law is not liable for SDLT. This means that the related documentation would still require stamp duty if it was completed under an oral agreement made before 10 July 2003 and either significantly executed before that date or not altered or assigned afterward.

This situation is particularly common with lease agreements. The way stamp duty applies to the rental element of a lease can differ from how it applies to a purchase.

Legal Requirements for Contracts in the UK

In the UK, the need for a written contract depends on the specific region: England and Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland. Here’s what the law says about contracts related to land transactions.

England & Wales

– Under the Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989, any contract for the sale or transfer of land interests must be in writing.
– The only exception is for a lease that meets the following criteria:
– It involves a market rent
– There is no premium involved
– The lease term does not exceed three years (i.e., it is an under-three-year lease)

This covers all types of tenancies, whether yearly, monthly, or weekly.

In practice, it is rare to have a prior oral or written agreement for an under-three-year lease. This is largely because such leases can often be granted simply through an oral arrangement.

Scotland

– According to the Requirements of Writing (Scotland) Act 1995, a written document is needed to create, transfer, vary, or end an interest in land.
– The one exception is a tenancy or other right to use land that lasts for a fixed period not exceeding one year.

In Scotland, periodic tenancies, which are agreements that renew automatically, do not exist.

Northern Ireland

– In Northern Ireland, there is no requirement for a contract concerning the sale or transfer of land to be in writing.
– Therefore, an oral contract for buying or leasing land is completely valid.

If an oral agreement is acted upon—for example, when a tenant takes possession of the property—it will usually be enforceable.

Post-Implementation Transactions

A transaction that occurs after the new SDLT rules can be seen as outside the scope of stamp duty land tax only if it is based on a contract agreed upon before the Royal Assent, which marked the implementation of the new rules.

This means that the transaction must align with the earlier agreement.

The Importance of Clarity in Lease Agreements

Most landlords and tenants prefer to have clear terms laid out in a lease, which can often be quite detailed. This makes it unlikely that parties will feel comfortable relying solely on an oral arrangement for anything but the simplest transactions. In these cases, having an additional written memorandum can help solidify the agreement.

Furthermore, a tenant might find it challenging to prove that the lease follows from an earlier oral agreement if there isn’t any written record to support their claim.

Types of Leases and Oral Agreements

For various types of leases, the following points are essential:
– A yearly, monthly, or weekly tenancy can indeed be granted orally, and there wouldn’t typically be a prior agreement for such leases.
– A lease that lasts for a fixed duration of less than one year can also be established through an oral contract.

In most instances, however, especially for leases that are more complicated, some form of written agreement is preferred.

Conclusion

In summary, the application of stamp duty land tax in relation to pre-royal assent oral contracts presents several considerations for taxpayers. The distinct regional legal requirements underscore the importance of understanding contract validity and the implications of oral versus written agreements when engaging in land transactions.