HMRC SDLT: SDLTM54110 – Overpayment relief: Exclusions: Case A mistake concerning a relief or election

Overpayment Relief: Exclusions – Case A

This section of the HMRC internal manual discusses the principles and concepts related to overpayment relief, specifically focusing on exclusions under Case A. It addresses mistakes concerning a relief or election.

• Explains the criteria for overpayment relief exclusions.
• Details the specific conditions under Case A.
• Clarifies the types of mistakes that do not qualify for relief.
• Provides guidance on handling such cases within HMRC.

Understanding Overpayment Relief: Exclusions Relating to Mistakes in Claims and Elections

This article focuses on the guidance regarding overpayment relief under HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) rules, specifically addressing situations involving mistakes in claims or elections. It is important to understand when overpayment relief is not applicable, particularly when the reasons behind the excessive amounts paid or due involve errors.

What is Overpayment Relief?

Overpayment relief is the process through which taxpayers can reclaim excess amounts they have paid in taxes. This relief can apply if you have mistakenly paid more tax than necessary due to misunderstandings or errors in your understanding of your tax obligations. However, there are specific circumstances in which overpayment relief does not apply.

Situations Where Overpayment Relief Does Not Apply

Overpayment relief is not available if the excess payment arises from mistakes made in the following contexts:

• Formal Claims or Elections: Overpayment relief is not granted if the amount due is higher than it should be because of a mistake in any formal claim or election made to HMRC. A formal claim or election refers to officially requesting a specific tax treatment or concession that affects the tax amount due.
• Failure to Make a Claim or Election: If someone does not make a required claim or election, and that lack of action results in a higher tax payment, they cannot seek overpayment relief for that amount.

Examples of When Overpayment Relief is Excluded

To clarify these situations, let’s look at a few examples:

Example 1: Incorrectly Filling Out a Claim

Imagine a taxpayer who fills out a claim for a specific tax relief but inadvertently provides incorrect information on the form. Due to this error, HMRC processes the claim in a way that results in a higher tax liability than the taxpayer should have. In this case, because the excess payment was caused by a mistake on the formal claim itself, the taxpayer cannot apply for overpayment relief. The focus here is on the fact that it was their error that led to the miscalculation, thus disqualifying them from relief.

Example 2: Missing a Deadline

Consider another scenario where a taxpayer fails to submit a formal election for a tax relief by the designated deadline. As a result, they end up paying more tax than they would have if they had submitted the election on time. Here, because the taxpayer did not take the necessary action (making the election), they are not entitled to overpayment relief. The principle is that one must follow due process in tax requirements to avoid penalties for overpayment.

Late Claims and Elections

There are some instances where HMRC may consider accepting late claims or elections. Exceptions can be made, but these are limited and specific. For more information on these rare cases, refer to the Assessment Claims Manual (SACM). You can find further details on late claims in section SACM10035.

Key Principles to Remember

Understanding the principles associated with overpayment relief and its exclusions helps taxpayers navigate their responsibilities correctly. Here are some key points to remember:

• Own Responsibility: Taxpayers are responsible for ensuring their claims and elections are accurate and submitted on time.
• Informal Guidance is Not Enough: Relying on informal advice or assumptions without making appropriate claims can lead to potential overpayment situations where relief is unavailable.
• Timeliness is Vital: Always be mindful of deadlines for claims and elections; missing them can affect tax liabilities significantly.

Conclusion

To avoid situations where overpayment relief cannot be claimed, it is essential to be vigilant and careful when filling out claims and elections with HMRC. Understanding the rules and ensuring compliance will help manage tax obligations effectively.

Useful article? You may find it helpful to read the original guidance here: HMRC SDLT: SDLTM54110 – Overpayment relief: Exclusions: Case A mistake concerning a relief or election

View all HMRC SDLT Guidance Pages Here