Guidance on Refusal of LBTT Payment Deferral Applications by Revenue Scotland

Refusal of Application for Deferral of LBTT Payment

This section provides guidance on the conditions under which Revenue Scotland may reject an application to defer Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (LBTT) payments due to contingent or uncertain considerations. It also outlines the subsequent steps following a refusal.

• Explanation of circumstances leading to application refusal.
• Details on contingent or uncertain considerations.
• Procedures following the refusal of deferral applications.
• Relevant legal and procedural guidelines.

Understanding the Refusal of Deferral Applications for Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (LBTT)

The Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (LBTT) is a tax applied to land transactions in Scotland, including the purchase of residential and commercial properties. In certain situations, taxpayers may wish to defer payment of LBTT, especially when the consideration is contingent or uncertain. However, Revenue Scotland has the authority to refuse such deferral applications under specific circumstances. This article explores the conditions under which deferral applications may be rejected, the implications of such refusals, and the steps taxpayers can take following a refusal.

What is LBTT?

LBTT is a tax that replaced the UK Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) in Scotland on 1 April 2015. It is payable on land and property transactions, with rates and bands set by the Scottish Government. The tax is progressive, meaning that the amount payable increases with the value of the property or land being purchased.

For more information on LBTT, visit the official Revenue Scotland LBTT page.

Deferral of LBTT Payment

In certain transactions, the total consideration for a property may not be clear at the time of purchase. This could be due to contingent or uncertain factors, such as future payments based on the property’s performance or other conditions. In such cases, taxpayers may apply to defer the payment of LBTT until the consideration becomes certain.

Contingent Consideration

Contingent consideration refers to payments that depend on future events. For example, a buyer might agree to pay additional amounts if a property generates a certain level of income. In these cases, the exact amount of LBTT due may not be known at the time of the transaction.

Uncertain Consideration

Uncertain consideration occurs when the final payment amount is not fixed and may vary based on specific factors, such as the outcome of a legal dispute or the completion of certain development milestones.

Reasons for Refusal of Deferral Applications

Revenue Scotland has the authority to refuse deferral applications under certain conditions. Understanding these reasons can help taxpayers prepare more robust applications and avoid potential refusals.

Insufficient Information

One of the primary reasons for refusal is the lack of sufficient information. Revenue Scotland requires detailed documentation to assess the validity of a deferral request. This includes clear evidence of the contingent or uncertain nature of the consideration and any supporting contracts or agreements.

Non-Compliance with Regulations

Applications that do not comply with the relevant regulations and guidelines are likely to be refused. Taxpayers must ensure that their applications meet all statutory requirements and provide all necessary details as stipulated by Revenue Scotland.

Unclear Justification

Another common reason for refusal is an unclear or inadequate justification for the deferral. Taxpayers must clearly explain why the consideration is contingent or uncertain and why deferral is necessary. Vague or unsupported claims are unlikely to be successful.

Implications of Refusal

If a deferral application is refused, the taxpayer is required to pay the LBTT based on the best estimate of the consideration at the time of the transaction. This can have several implications:

Immediate Payment Obligation

A refusal means that the taxpayer must pay the LBTT immediately, which could impact cash flow, especially if the estimated consideration is significant.

Potential for Reassessment

If the final consideration differs from the initial estimate, there may be a need for reassessment. This could result in additional payments or refunds, depending on whether the final consideration is higher or lower than the estimate.

Steps Following a Refusal

Taxpayers who have their deferral applications refused have several options to consider:

Review and Resubmit

If the refusal was due to insufficient information or unclear justification, taxpayers can review their applications, gather additional documentation, and resubmit their requests. It is important to address all the reasons for the initial refusal in the revised application.

Seek Professional Advice

Engaging a tax professional or legal advisor can provide valuable insights and guidance on how to strengthen a deferral application. Professionals can help ensure compliance with regulations and improve the likelihood of a successful application.

Appeal the Decision

If a taxpayer believes that their application was wrongly refused, they may have the option to appeal the decision. The appeals process involves presenting additional evidence or arguments to support the case for deferral.

For more information on the appeals process, visit the Revenue Scotland Appeals page.

Conclusion

Understanding the conditions under which Revenue Scotland may refuse a deferral application for LBTT is essential for taxpayers dealing with contingent or uncertain considerations. By providing comprehensive information, complying with regulations, and clearly justifying the need for deferral, taxpayers can improve their chances of a successful application. In cases of refusal, reviewing the application, seeking professional advice, or appealing the decision are viable steps to consider.

For further guidance on LBTT and deferral applications, visit the official Revenue Scotland guidance page.

Useful article? You may find it helpful to read the original guidance here: Guidance on Refusal of LBTT Payment Deferral Applications by Revenue Scotland

View all LBTT Guidance Pages Here