Disputes with Revenue Scotland: how it settles LBTT and tax disagreements

In short

Revenue Scotland’s published principles explain how it settles disputes over LBTT and other devolved taxes. They are guidance, not law, but they shape what deal you can expect.

  • It aims to settle by agreement, including mediation where appropriate, at any stage.
  • It will not split the difference, trade disputed points or compromise its view of the law.
  • In genuinely all-or-nothing cases it will not settle for less than the tax, penalties and interest it considers due, while weighing the best practicable result.
  • Separately, the law lets you ask for a review of an appealable decision by giving notice with grounds within 30 days after you were notified, unless you have already appealed or have a settlement agreement in place.

Scroll down for the full analysis.

Nick Garner

Need an indemnified letter of advice? Email me your situation — my initial assessment is always free. If a formal letter is needed, fixed fee from £350, no VAT.

✉️ [email protected]

Insured by Markel International (up to £250k per claim). Learn more →

Disputes with Revenue Scotland: how it settles LBTT and tax disagreements

If you disagree with Revenue Scotland about Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (LBTT), the tax that replaced stamp duty land tax in Scotland in 2015, it will usually try to reach an agreement with you. But it has firm limits. It will not split the difference, swap one point for another, or bend its view of the law just to close the case.

What this rule is about

Tax disagreements happen all the time. You might think your purchase qualifies for a relief. Revenue Scotland might not. Or you might disagree about what a property is worth.

Revenue Scotland has published 13 Settlement and Litigation Principles. They explain how it handles these disagreements, from the first questions right through to a tribunal hearing. Litigation just means taking the dispute to a tribunal or court.

Why publish them at all? Revenue Scotland says openness helps both sides. It says what it will do, then does it. You know where you stand.

The principles cover the devolved Scottish taxes, including LBTT, plus the interest and penalties that go with them.

One point matters before anything else: this is guidance, not law. Revenue Scotland says so itself. More on why that still matters below.

What the official source says

The principles fall into two groups. Here is what Revenue Scotland says it will try to do:

  • settle by agreement where it can, including through mediation where that fits
  • stay open to a deal at any stage, even once a case is before a tribunal
  • apply the law reasonably and consistently to every taxpayer
  • treat people in the same or similar arrangements consistently
  • resolve disputes quickly, and agree early on what is not in dispute
  • spot early when it needs expert advice, and get it promptly
  • get the best practicable result for the Exchequer, meaning the public purse
  • follow its published values, set out in its Scottish Approach to Tax and its Charter of Standards and Values

And here is what it says it will not do:

  • shy away from a tribunal when that is needed to defend its view
  • settle for less than the full tax, penalties and interest where the issue is genuinely all or nothing, while still weighing the best practicable result
  • trade one disputed point against another
  • split the difference
  • compromise on its view of the law to get a deal

“Dispute” is read widely. It means any disagreement about how much tax is due, at any stage. That includes the early stage when Revenue Scotland is still asking for information, long before any formal decision.

The principles do not cover everything, though. They apply only to civil disagreements about whether something is taxable or how much tax is due. They do not cover:

  • tax that is properly due but simply unpaid
  • requests to postpone tax
  • collection action or time to pay arrangements
  • fraud or other criminal behaviour
  • disagreements with Revenue Scotland that are not about tax

What this means in practice

Start with the status. Revenue Scotland says neither the principles nor its guidance have the force of law. So you cannot enforce them like a statute.

That does not make them worthless to you. Revenue Scotland accepts they could matter in an argument about whether it acted lawfully, fairly, rationally and reasonably. Judicial review, a court challenge to how a public body made a decision, is one example it gives.

Mediation is the next point. Revenue Scotland says it will agree to mediation unless it thinks that is not in the public interest. Its guidance says mediation is most likely to help where:

  • communication between you and Revenue Scotland has broken down
  • there is a basic misunderstanding about the facts
  • it is unclear how Revenue Scotland has used information

It is less likely to help where you simply read the law differently, or the outcome can only be all or nothing. The cost of mediation is shared equally, so weigh that too.

What about the formal route? The law gives you a right, separate from these principles, to ask Revenue Scotland to review an appealable decision. That covers decisions affecting whether you owe tax, how much, or when it must be paid. The key rules are:

  • you must give notice of review to Revenue Scotland within 30 days after the date you were notified of the decision
  • your notice must set out your grounds
  • Revenue Scotland must tell you its view within 30 days beginning with the day it receives your notice, or a longer period if that is reasonable
  • the review can uphold, vary or cancel the decision
  • you cannot ask for a review if you have already appealed on the same matter, or have a settlement agreement you have not withdrawn from

Missed the 30 days? A late review is possible if Revenue Scotland agrees or the tribunal gives permission. Revenue Scotland must agree if you had a reasonable excuse and asked without unreasonable delay.

Notice something about who starts litigation. Revenue Scotland says it generally does not. You do, by appealing. That is why it says it must get its decisions right first time.

How to analyse it

If you are in a disagreement now, work through these questions in order:

  • Is this really a dispute about how much tax is due, or is it about collection, time to pay or unpaid tax?
  • How many separate points are in dispute? Each will be dealt with on its own.
  • What is already agreed? Pin that down early.
  • Is the answer all or nothing, or could it fall anywhere in a range?
  • Has Revenue Scotland issued a formal decision? If so, the 30-day review clock is running.
  • Would mediation help, or is this purely a difference over the law?
  • Do you have new facts or arguments? Revenue Scotland says it will consider them at any stage.

Example

These are illustrations, not real cases.

Fiona’s return claimed a relief. After an enquiry, Revenue Scotland decides the relief does not apply and she owes an extra £8,000. Either the relief applies or it does not. Fiona offers £4,000 to settle. If Revenue Scotland thinks it is more likely than not to win, it will refuse. Half-way is not on the table.

Change one fact. Lomond Ltd buys land from a seller connected with it. The LBTT Act says the price for tax cannot be less than the land’s market value, subject to some exceptions. Lomond’s return used £400,000. Revenue Scotland’s valuer says £460,000.

Valuation is a range, not a yes or no. Revenue Scotland is not bound to accept £400,000. It aims at the figure it reasonably expects a tribunal to reach. If that genuinely sits in between, agreement there is possible. The middle figure matters only if it is the likely result, not because it is the middle.

Now the common mistake. Alasdair has two separate disputes. He offers to give way on one if Revenue Scotland drops the other. It will not do that swap. Each point is judged on its merits, though Revenue Scotland may consider how pursuing one affects the others, or accept a changed approach for future years.

Why this can be difficult in practice

Revenue Scotland admits the principles can pull against each other. It calls them guidelines that need judgement, not rules. That leaves grey areas:

  • “Best practicable result for the Exchequer” is broad. It weighs likely tax, legal costs, chances of winning, effects on other disputes and the deterrent effect, and the balance can shift over time.
  • “More likely than not to win” is Revenue Scotland’s own view. Expert advice informs it, but Revenue Scotland does not generally share that advice with you.
  • Consistent treatment does not mean identical treatment. Your facts will rarely match someone else’s exactly.
  • Formal steps, such as information requests or assessments, are not a sign that Revenue Scotland has stopped cooperating.
  • Whether a case is truly all or nothing can itself be arguable.
  • If Revenue Scotland amends your figures during an enquiry, you cannot ask for a review of that until the enquiry is finished.

In a genuinely all-or-nothing case, Revenue Scotland says it will usually stop defending an appeal it thinks it is unlikely to win. Usually, not always. It may carry on where the law needs clarifying or many taxpayers could be affected.

Finally, the guidance was last updated on 20 November 2023. Revenue Scotland says it will revise it as experience grows, so check the current version.

Key takeaways

  • Revenue Scotland will try to settle LBTT and other devolved tax disputes by agreement, at any stage.
  • The principles are guidance, not law, but can matter if you challenge how Revenue Scotland acted.
  • Do not expect it to split the difference or swap one point for another.
  • Where tax could fall in a range, it aims at what it expects a tribunal to decide, not the lowest figure.
  • Mediation is usually available, with costs shared equally, but suits some disputes better than others.
  • To ask for a review of an appealable decision, give notice with your grounds within 30 days after you were notified of it.

Technical analysis

For advisers, and for anyone who wants to check the law behind this page. You do not need this section to understand the guidance above.

Legislation

Official guidance

The pages below are Revenue Scotland’s guidance. Guidance is not law. It sets out how Revenue Scotland reads the legislation, and it is not binding on you, on a tribunal or on a court. Where guidance and the legislation differ, the legislation wins. Revenue Scotland can also change or withdraw guidance, and it may not cover your facts.

  • Revenue Scotland, RSTP6001A Settlement and Litigation Principles and accompanying guidance (last updated 20 November 2023)

Where this is not settled

  • The best practicable result for the Exchequer is a broad, multi-factor test that Revenue Scotland applies itself and that can change during a dispute.
  • Revenue Scotland’s view of whether it is more likely than not to win is its own judgement, and it does not generally share the expert advice behind it.
  • Whether a dispute is genuinely all or nothing, or allows a range of outcomes, is not always clear and affects how settlement works.
  • The statutory provisions on settlement agreements and mediation referred to in the review rules (including RSTPA 2014 s.246) were not in the supplied text, so their detail is not covered here.
  • The guidance is dated 20 November 2023 and Revenue Scotland says it will be revised as experience grows.

Evidence you would need

This kind of case is decided on the facts of the individual property. These are the records that usually settle it, and the ones an adviser would ask you for.

  • Copy of any decision notice from Revenue Scotland and the date you were notified of it
  • A clear list of each separate point in dispute and what is already agreed
  • Any new facts, documents or technical arguments supporting your position
  • Valuation evidence where the dispute is about market value
  • Records of correspondence showing any breakdown in communication or misunderstanding of facts, if seeking mediation

Explore this with an AI

Nick Garner

An AI will give you plenty of information. It will not take responsibility for any of it. When a conveyancing solicitor asks for professional tax advice, responsibility is what they are really asking for: a named adviser who has looked at your facts and carries indemnity insurance for the view they reach.

Email me your circumstances and I will give you my honest opinion, free. About half the time that is the end of it. If your solicitor wants it in writing, a formal letter of advice starts at £350, no VAT.

If it helped and you never need the letter, a Google review or a charity donation is welcome. Never expected.

Email me about your situation[email protected]

Nick Garner

Readers often want to test their own situation. Copy the prompt below into ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini. It hands the model the actual legislation for this page rather than letting it answer from memory, and tells it to be explicit about what is uncertain. What comes back is information, not advice – check it against the links above.

I am researching Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (LBTT), the tax on property in Scotland. It replaced Stamp Duty Land Tax in Scotland on 1 April 2015, and SDLT does not apply in Scotland.

MY QUESTION
Disputes with Revenue Scotland: how it settles LBTT and tax disagreements

[Replace this with your own situation: what you are buying, the price,
the dates, who the buyer is, and what you plan to do with the property.]

THE LAW THIS TURNS ON
- LBTT(S)A 2013 section 1 - creates LBTT and gives the tax authority its management role
  https://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2013/11/section/1
- LBTT(S)A 2013 section 54 - confirms Revenue Scotland is the tax authority for LBTT
  https://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2013/11/section/54
- LBTT(S)A 2013 section 22 - market value floor where a company buys from a connected seller
  https://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2013/11/section/22
- RSTPA 2014 section 85 - Revenue Scotland's power to open an enquiry into a return
  https://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2014/16/section/85
- RSTPA 2014 section 87 - amending a self-assessment during an enquiry to prevent tax loss
  https://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2014/16/section/87
- RSTPA 2014 section 98 - assessment where Revenue Scotland believes tax has been lost
  https://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2014/16/section/98
- RSTPA 2014 section 233 - which Revenue Scotland decisions can be reviewed and appealed
  https://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2014/16/section/233
- RSTPA 2014 section 234 - right to ask for a review and when it is barred
  https://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2014/16/section/234
- RSTPA 2014 section 235 - 30-day time limit and content of a review request
  https://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2014/16/section/235
- RSTPA 2014 section 236 - asking for a review after the time limit has passed
  https://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2014/16/section/236
- RSTPA 2014 section 237 - Revenue Scotland's duty to give its view and carry out review
  https://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2014/16/section/237
- RSTPA 2014 section 238 - how a review is carried out and its possible outcomes
  https://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2014/16/section/238

Guidance page from Revenue Scotland on this topic (guidance, not law):
https://revenue.scot/taxes/legislation/rstpa-legislation-guidance/rstp6001-dispute-resolution/rstp6001a-revenue-scotland-settlement-litigation

HOW I WANT YOU TO ANSWER
1. Work from the legislation above. Read it before answering.
   Guidance from Revenue Scotland is its view of the law, not the
   law, and does not bind a tribunal or a court.
2. Tell me what the rule actually requires, in plain English.
3. Tell me which facts decide the answer, and which facts would change it.
4. Tell me what evidence I would need to support the position.
5. Be explicit about anything unsettled or fact-sensitive. Do not guess.
6. Your training data has a cutoff and SDLT rates and reliefs change at
   fiscal events. Say so if you are not sure the law is current.

POINTS ALREADY KNOWN TO BE UNCERTAIN ON THIS TOPIC
- The best practicable result for the Exchequer is a broad, multi-factor test that Revenue Scotland applies itself and that can change during a dispute.
- Revenue Scotland's view of whether it is more likely than not to win is its own judgement, and it does not generally share the expert advice behind it.
- Whether a dispute is genuinely all or nothing, or allows a range of outcomes, is not always clear and affects how settlement works.

Do not give me a conclusion you cannot support from the provisions above.

Legislation links show the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Scotland) Act 2013 as it stood on 2025-11-17. The law may have changed since, and the rules that apply are those in force on the date of your transaction. The official guidance this page is based on is here.

This page was last updated on 16 November 2026

Useful article? You may find it helpful to read the original guidance here: Disputes with Revenue Scotland: how it settles LBTT and tax disagreements

View all LBTT Guidance Pages Here

Search Land Tax Advice with Google

What people say

Most of these Google reviews are from people who emailed me a question and got a helpful written answer. That is step 1 below, and it is genuinely free.

Valentina Menale profile picture
Valentina Menale

1 week ago
I cannot recommend Nick and Land Tax Advice highly enough. From start to finish, the service was outstanding. Nick was incredibly quick to respond and turn things around, while also being exceptionally thorough. He took the time to explain everything in detail, including quite complex SDLT rules and technical points, but always in clear, straightforward plain English. Nothing felt rushed or glossed over, and I always understood exactly what was being considered and why. What really stood out was his willingness to go the extra mile. He carefully reviewed all the evidence I provided, and was also approachable, patient and happy to answer all my questions, no matter how specific. The service represents exceptional value for money, particularly considering the level of expertise, time and attention to detail involved. I also think it is fantastic that Nick offers an initial free consultation, giving you the opportunity to explain your situation, understand your options and get an idea of how he can help before committing to anything. This says a lot about his approach and willingness to help. I genuinely felt that Nick cared about getting things right and providing the best possible support, rather than simply completing a piece of work. If you need specialist advice on SDLT, particularly where overseas property ownership or the higher rates are involved, I would recommend Nick without hesitation.
Qaisar Raja profile picture
Qaisar Raja

1 week ago
I cannot thank Nick enough for the exceptional advice and support he provided regarding my stamp duty query. Before coming across Nick at Land Tax Advice, I had spoken to several other advisers, but unfortunately, nobody was able to give me a clear or definitive answer. My situation was not straightforward, and I was struggling to find someone who could provide the clarity and reassurance I needed. Then I came across Nick, and what a difference that made! Nick provided an incredibly detailed, thorough and well-researched response. I can only imagine the time and effort he must have invested in looking into my situation, as it certainly wasn't a question that could be answered with a quick search or a generic response. He went through everything carefully, explained the position in a way that was easy to understand and, most importantly, supported his advice with relevant HMRC guidance, examples and evidence. What makes this experience even more remarkable is that he provided all this advice completely free of charge. Not a single penny was requested or charged. I honestly cannot express how much I appreciate this level of generosity. In today's world, where professional advice can come at a significant cost, finding someone who is willing to dedicate their time, expertise and knowledge to help a complete stranger without expecting anything in return is truly special. Nick was completely transparent, honest and professional throughout. He didn't simply give me an answer for the sake of it; he took the time to explain the reasoning behind it and provide the supporting evidence so that I could understand and feel confident about the advice. This experience says a great deal about Nick as a person, not just as a professional. His willingness to help others, his generosity and his genuine approach are qualities that deserve to be recognised and appreciated. People like Nick restore your faith in others and remind you that there are still genuinely good people out there. People like him really do make the world a more beautiful place. I would wholeheartedly recommend Nick and Land Tax Advice to anyone looking for honest, knowledgeable and reliable initial guidance on stamp duty or land tax matters. If you are struggling to get a clear answer elsewhere, I would strongly encourage you to speak to Nick. Thank you so much, Nick, for your time, patience, generosity and, above all, for going above and beyond to help me. Your advice was invaluable, and your kindness was equally appreciated. I genuinely wish you every success, because people who are willing to help others in the way you do deserve nothing but the very best. A truly outstanding experience. Highly recommended!
Darren Turpin profile picture
Darren Turpin

2 weeks ago
I contacted Nick for advice on a complicated Stamp Duty Land Tax refund claim involving exceptional circumstances, and was hugely impressed by the time, care and attention he devoted to understanding our situation. His advice was exceptionally thorough, carefully considered and clearly explained. He took the time to examine the details of our case, assess the strength of our argument and help us understand the best way to present it to HMRC. What particularly stood out was his openness, honesty and generosity. He was refreshingly straightforward about the merits of our case, never overstating our chances of success or suggesting anything that wasn't supported by the evidence. It was clear that his priority was giving us the best possible advice, with our interests firmly at heart. Nick combines specialist knowledge and professionalism with genuine kindness and integrity. I'm extremely grateful for his help and wouldn't hesitate to recommend him to anyone needing SDLT advice.
Long Nguyen profile picture
Long Nguyen

2 weeks ago
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Outstanding Professional Service, Genuine Care and Exceptional Support We cannot thank Nick Garner enough for his outstanding professionalism, expertise and genuine care throughout our journey of purchasing our first family home. From our very first conversation, Nick demonstrated exceptional knowledge, patience and attention to detail. He took the time to thoroughly understand our circumstances, carefully review our documents and explain complex Stamp Duty matters in a clear, practical and reassuring way. What truly sets Nick apart is his willingness to go above and beyond what is expected. He even took the time to review the available advice packages with us before we made our decision, helping us understand which service would best suit our needs rather than simply recommending the most expensive option. His advice was always honest, thoughtful and focused on our best interests. Throughout the process, Nick has been incredibly responsive, approachable and supportive. He has consistently provided detailed explanations, answered our questions with great patience and offered valuable guidance, even on matters beyond his original scope of work. When our family unexpectedly faced a difficult personal situation during the house-buying process, Nick showed genuine compassion and continued to support us with kindness, understanding and practical advice. That level of personal care is something we will always remember and deeply appreciate. It is rare to find a professional who combines such excellent technical expertise with genuine integrity, empathy and dedication to his clients. Nick has not simply been a tax adviser to us; he has been a trusted professional who has supported and guided our family through an important chapter of our lives. We wholeheartedly recommend Nick Garner to anyone seeking expert Stamp Duty advice and a truly exceptional level of service. Thank you, Nick, for your professionalism, honesty, patience and, above all, for genuinely caring about the people you help. We are sincerely grateful for everything you have done for our family. Long & Lien
Lin McLaughlin profile picture
Lin McLaughlin

3 weeks ago
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I cannot recommend Nick at Land Tax Advice highly enough. I contacted Nick for urgent advice regarding a complicated Stamp Duty Land Tax matter connected with our property purchase. After I sent him a substantial number of documents, he took the time to review everything thoroughly and provided an exceptionally detailed explanation of our situation and the options available to us. What really stood out was how quickly and efficiently he dealt with my enquiry, particularly as he understood how urgent the matter was. His advice was clear, comprehensive and explained in a way that was easy to understand, even when dealing with complicated tax matters. Nick was also incredibly kind, approachable and generous with his time. Having been through a particularly stressful property transaction, finding someone so knowledgeable, responsive and genuinely willing to help has been an absolute godsend. Thank you, Nick, for your expertise, your kindness and for going above and beyond when I really needed help. I would recommend Land Tax Advice without hesitation to anyone needing specialist advice on Stamp Duty or land tax matters.

See All Reviews

£350
NO VAT
— Indemnified Letter of Advice
Fixed fee £350 for most letters. Complex cases up to £1,250 — always quoted in advance. Insured by Markel International up to £250,000 per claim.

Nick Garner

Conveyancer holding things up until they have written SDLT advice? I’ll provide a formal, insured opinion from a registered tax agent so they can proceed.

How it works

1

Email me the details of your situation. I’ll reply in writing — free of charge — with a clear explanation of your legal position.

2

You decide whether that’s enough. Often the free email is all you need — you can forward it to your solicitor for their own assessment.

3

If a formal letter is needed, we go from there. I’ll quote you a fixed fee before any paid work begins.

Start with step 1. No commitment, no cost — just email me your situation and I’ll clarify the legal position.

✉️ Email: [email protected]

Replies usually the same working day. Nick Garner, registered tax agent.