HMRC v Ridgway [2024] UKUT 36 (TCC): Lease Restrictions and Unclaimed Relief
In HMRC v Ridgway the Upper Tribunal decided two points.
Every enquiry is answered by me personally.
First, legal restrictions on use, such as a lease covenant against residential use or the planning position, are relevant to whether a building is "suitable for use as a dwelling", but neither is decisive; on the facts a garden building let to a photographic studio two weeks before completion was still residential. Second, multiple dwellings relief had to be claimed in a return or an amended return. Because it had not been, neither HMRC nor the tribunal could give it when the enquiry was closed.
The buyer paid SDLT at the full residential rates, without the relief he would have had if he had claimed it in time.
Law as at November 2026.
The case at a glance
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Citation | The Commissioners for HMRC v Daniel Ridgway [2024] UKUT 36 (TCC) |
| Court | Upper Tribunal (Tax and Chancery Chamber), on HMRC's appeal from the First-tier Tribunal |
| Judges | Judge Jonathan Cannan and Judge Vimal Tilakapala |
| Dates | Heard 6 November 2023; decision released 9 February 2024 |
| Result | HMRC's appeal allowed. The property was wholly residential and multiple dwellings relief was not available. |
The facts
On 23 August 2017 Mr Ridgway bought, for £6.5 million, a semi-detached house and gardens in Oxford together with an adjoining building on a separate title with its own access, the Old Summer House. It had been built as a garage and later used as an artist's studio. It had a kitchenette, a shower room and two rooms that could be bedrooms, and a certificate of lawful use from 1996 for use as an independent residential unit.
On his solicitor's advice, and at his instigation, the vendors granted a six-month commercial lease of the Old Summer House to a photographic studio two weeks before completion. The lease prohibited residential use. His return treated the purchase as mixed use, with SDLT of £314,500. At residential rates the tax was £888,750; with multiple dwellings relief it would have been £577,500.
HMRC opened an enquiry in May 2018 and closed it in February 2021, concluding that the Old Summer House was suitable for use as a dwelling and amending the return to the residential rates without the relief. The time for Mr Ridgway to amend his own return had expired in September 2018.
The First-tier Tribunal held that the lease made the building unsuitable for use as a dwelling, but went on to apply the anti-avoidance rule in section 75A of the Finance Act 2003, a point neither party had raised, and allowed multiple dwellings relief although it had not been claimed.
The questions
- Can a private law restriction in a lease be taken into account in deciding whether a building is suitable for use as a dwelling, and was the planning position also relevant?
- Did section 75A apply?
- If the property was residential, did HMRC, or the tribunal, have to give multiple dwellings relief that had never been claimed?
The decision and the reasoning
Suitability for use: legal restrictions count, but do not decide
The test is objective, and the buyer's intentions are irrelevant. The Upper Tribunal rejected HMRC's argument that only physical attributes matter. Suitability may involve a wide range of factors, including restrictions on use in leases, freehold covenants, planning and environmental law. Each is a factor in a multi-factorial assessment, not a decisive one. What counts is the existence of a restriction: "It is the existence of the restrictions which are relevant factors, not the likelihood of enforcement."
The First-tier Tribunal had not dealt with the planning position at all, which was an error of law. Remaking the decision, the Upper Tribunal found the building physically suitable for use as a dwelling, with planning status as an independent residential unit and no history of separate commercial use. The lease was granted two weeks before completion for six months. Commercial use was restricted by planning law and residential use by the lease. With the legal restrictions pointing both ways, the tribunal held that on these facts the physical attributes were dominant. The Old Summer House was residential.
Section 75A did not apply
Both parties agreed, and the tribunal held, that section 75A was not engaged: the consideration for the actual transactions and for the notional transaction was the same £6.5 million, so the tax could not be lower.
An unclaimed relief cannot be given at the end of an enquiry
Section 58D(2) required multiple dwellings relief to be claimed in a land transaction return or an amendment of one. An enquiry extends to what is in the return or required to be in it; an optional relief that has not been claimed is neither. HMRC therefore did not have to give it in the closure notice, and the tribunal could not reduce the assessment for a relief outside the scope of the appeal. The tribunal accepted that this might be said to be unfair, but SDLT is a self-assessed tax with hard-edged deadlines: "Where a relief requires a claim, and a claim is not made in accordance with any procedural requirements, the taxpayer will not be entitled to relief."
Where it sits now
Ridgway is an Upper Tribunal decision and binds the First-tier Tribunal. In Mudan v HMRC [2025] EWCA Civ 799 the Court of Appeal reviewed it among the tribunal decisions on section 116 and described that body of case law as showing a consistent approach. See the Mudan page.
Multiple dwellings relief was abolished for transactions with an effective date on or after 1 June 2024, subject to a transitional rule for contracts exchanged before 6 March 2024, so the relief itself is now largely of historical interest. The procedural point remains: where the legislation requires a relief or treatment to be claimed in a return or amendment, it must be claimed in that way and in time. An amendment can be made within 12 months of the filing date.
What it means in practice
For buyers
- Arranging a short commercial letting of part of a residential property shortly before completion is unlikely to change its classification where the building is physically suitable as a dwelling.
- Choosing a lower-tax treatment in the return carries the risk of losing a fallback that had to be claimed. In Ridgway the buyer ended up paying more than he would have done had he claimed the relief from the outset.
For conveyancers
- Check whether any relief relevant to the transaction must be claimed in the return. A claim not made in the return or in a timely amendment may be lost, even if HMRC later enquire.
- Where a lease, covenant or planning restriction is said to make a building non-residential, weigh it against the building's physical attributes, its planning status and its history. A restriction is one factor, not the answer.
The decision
Free informal view
Find out where you stand
Email me the facts, with any documents and correspondence. I will find out what is needed and give you my informal view, free of charge, so you know where you stand before deciding what, if anything, should follow.
If you or your conveyancer need advice you can rely on, a formal Letter of Advice is a separate piece of work, from £350 with no VAT. I will tell you whether one is worth having, and the fee, before anything starts.




