SDLT Case Law: The Leading Tribunal and Court Decisions

The decisions below are the ones that most often settle Stamp Duty Land Tax questions in practice: whether a building is a dwelling, whether land is part of the garden or grounds, and how reliefs and claims must be made.

Every enquiry is answered by me personally.

Each entry gives the citation, the court, what was decided and what it means.

Weight depends on the court. Court of Appeal and Supreme Court decisions bind the tribunals. Upper Tribunal decisions bind the First-tier Tribunal. First-tier Tribunal decisions bind no one and are persuasive only, and many turn on their own facts.

Law as at November 2026. A selection of leading decisions, not a complete list.

Dwelling status and mixed use

Whether a building is "used or suitable for use as a dwelling", and whether land is part of its "garden or grounds", under section 116 of the Finance Act 2003. The answer decides whether the residential or the non-residential rates apply.

CaseCourtIssueOutcomeTakeaway
Mudan v HMRC
[2025] EWCA Civ 799
Court of AppealHouse needing rewiring, heating, a kitchen and other worksResidential. HMRC won.A building that has kept its character as a dwelling is suitable for use as one, even if it is not ready to move into.
P N Bewley Ltd v HMRC
[2019] UKFTT 65 (TC)
First-tier TribunalBungalow bought for demolition, with asbestos and heating removedNot a dwelling. Taxpayer won.Persuasive only, on exceptional facts; read it with Mudan.
HMRC v Ridgway
[2024] UKUT 36 (TCC)
Upper TribunalGarden building let to a studio two weeks before completionResidential. HMRC won.Legal restrictions on use are relevant but not decisive; physical suitability dominated.
Hyman v HMRC
[2022] EWCA Civ 185
Court of AppealHouses with 3.5 and 4.5 acresAll residential. HMRC won.There is no size limit on garden or grounds, and no "reasonable enjoyment" test.
HMRC v Suterwalla
[2024] UKUT 188 (TCC)
Upper TribunalSeparately titled paddock, screened from the houseMixed use. Taxpayers won.Land is judged as it stood at completion; a grazing lease granted afterwards is disregarded.
The How Development 1 Ltd v HMRC
[2023] UKUT 84 (TCC)
Upper TribunalAbout two acres of woodland that was hard to accessResidential. HMRC won.Difficult access and passive use do not stop land being grounds.
HMRC v Brzezicki
[2026] UKUT 125 (TCC)
Upper TribunalStream and island sold with a houseResidential. HMRC won.Later use and intentions do not answer the completion-date question.
Faiers v HMRC
[2023] UKFTT 297 (TC)
First-tier TribunalElectricity network infrastructure on the landResidential. HMRC won.Utility rights over land are generally consistent with it remaining grounds.
Inngrays Ltd v HMRC
[2026] UKFTT 1478 (TC)
First-tier TribunalSubstation let exclusively to the network operator since 1963Mixed use. Taxpayer won.Complete, long-standing exclusion of the owner took the land outside the grounds. Recent and open to appeal.

Higher rates

The higher rates for additional dwellings in Schedule 4ZA, and the single rate for companies buying dwellings over £500,000. The surcharge is 5% for transactions with an effective date on or after 31 October 2024 (previously 3%), and the company rate is 17% (previously 15%).

CaseCourtIssueOutcomeTakeaway
Mayfair Avenue Ltd v HMRC
[2024] UKFTT 430 (TC)
First-tier TribunalDirector's family home transferred to his company, with the family still living thereCompany rate applied (then 15%). HMRC won.The relief for property rental businesses fails where a non-qualifying individual occupies; the tribunal has no power to relieve on grounds of fairness.
Moaref and Mozhdeh v HMRC
[2020] UKFTT 396 (TC)
First-tier TribunalTwo adjoining flats bought weeks apart to be combinedHigher rates applied. HMRC won.Neither flat alone was the only or main residence, so the replacement exception failed.

Reliefs and procedure

CaseCourtIssueOutcomeTakeaway
HMRC v Ridgway
[2024] UKUT 36 (TCC)
Upper TribunalMultiple dwellings relief not claimed in the returnRelief refused. HMRC won.A relief that must be claimed in a return or amendment cannot be given at the end of an enquiry.
Fiander and Brower v HMRC
[2021] UKUT 156 (TCC)
Upper TribunalAnnex claimed as a separate dwelling for multiple dwellings reliefRelief refused. HMRC won.A single dwelling needs privacy, self-sufficiency and security; the test is objective.
Project Blue Ltd v HMRC
[2018] UKSC 30
Supreme CourtPurchase structured through a series of transactionsSection 75A applied. HMRC won.The anti-avoidance rule in section 75A can apply without any avoidance motive.
Martland v HMRC
[2018] UKUT 178 (TCC)
Upper TribunalPermission to appeal out of timeThree-stage test set out.Late appeals are judged on the length of and reasons for the delay and all the circumstances; deadlines matter.

Multiple dwellings relief was abolished for transactions with an effective date on or after 1 June 2024, subject to a transitional rule for contracts exchanged before 6 March 2024.

Using case law on your own facts. Most of these decisions turn on findings of fact. A favourable outcome in one case does not create a category rule, and a claim that relies on a First-tier Tribunal decision carries more risk than one supported by appellate authority. Where a return or a claim depends on how a case applies, take advice first.

Topics

The rules, questions and answers, and official guidance on each subject.

Free informal view

Find out where you stand

Email me the facts, with any documents and correspondence. I will find out what is needed and give you my informal view, free of charge, so you know where you stand before deciding what, if anything, should follow.

If you or your conveyancer need advice you can rely on, a formal Letter of Advice is a separate piece of work, from £350 with no VAT. I will tell you whether one is worth having, and the fee, before anything starts.

Email [email protected]Call 0204 577 3323

Related pages