Question

SDLT Enquiry Dropped: Can I Claim Compensation From HMRC?

The short answer

Often, but through a complaint rather than the courts. If HMRC made a mistake or handled your stamp duty enquiry unreasonably, their own guidance allows them to reimburse reasonable costs, such as adviser’s fees, and to make a modest payment for distress. Legal action is rarely proportionate. Winning the argument is not enough on its own. You need to show what HMRC did wrong, and evidence your costs.

Answered by Nick Garner, from a question emailed to me.
Land tax adviser and registered tax agent. Every enquiry is answered by me personally.

Law as at November 2026.

Your situation

HMRC opened an enquiry into your Stamp Duty Land Tax return, perhaps into a relief you claimed or the rate you paid. They raised an assessment, possibly with a penalty, and you spent months defending it with professional help. Then, on review, HMRC accepted that their case could not stand, and a refund is due.

You are relieved, but you have paid fees you feel you should never have faced, and the stress has been real. You want to know whether HMRC can be made to put that right.

My answer, and why

Often, yes, but not usually through the courts. In theory there are legal routes to take action against HMRC. In practice they are rarely proportionate: they are slow, expensive and uncertain, and they can cost more than they recover. The sensible route is usually a formal complaint, with a request for redress and reimbursement of costs.

What the complaints route is for

HMRC have published guidance on putting things right when they get something wrong. Its purpose is to restore you, as far as money can, to where you would have been without the error. It is not designed to punish HMRC. Broadly, it allows two kinds of payment: reimbursement of costs you reasonably incurred because of HMRC’s mistake or unreasonable handling, and a separate, modest payment for worry and distress.

Winning is not the same as being wronged

This is the usual misunderstanding. HMRC are entitled to enquire into a return and to take a view you disagree with. If the dispute was a genuine difference of opinion about the law, and you won, HMRC will not usually pay your costs only because you turned out to be right. What their guidance looks for is a mistake, unreasonable delay, or a case pursued when HMRC’s own position was plainly wrong.

So your complaint has to show what HMRC did wrong, not only that you won. Where HMRC have accepted in writing that they got something wrong, for example that a notice, assessment or penalty should not have been issued, that is an error on their side. It is a much stronger starting point than a lost argument.

What you can realistically recover

The big challenge is evidence. Costs are usually the strongest head of loss: adviser’s and accountant’s fees, and other reasonable costs of defending the case, provided they flowed from HMRC’s error and were reasonable in amount. Distress is real but harder to value, so it needs to be explained clearly and supported as well as possible. HMRC’s payments for worry and distress tend to be limited, and they are not damages of the kind a court might award.

I know that can feel unbalanced against what you went through. But the outcome turns on what you can show, not on how strongly you feel. That is the important point.

What would change the answer

  • Your appeal had already reached the First-tier Tribunal. The tribunal can order HMRC to pay costs if they acted unreasonably in bringing, defending or conducting the proceedings. That is a separate route with a short time limit: the application must be made within 28 days after the tribunal sends its decision, or the notice of a withdrawal that ends the appeal. It is aimed at the costs of the tribunal proceedings rather than everything before them.
  • HMRC have not yet withdrawn the assessment or penalty. Then the tax comes first, through review or appeal. A complaint will not decide whether tax is due, and it does not stop the appeal time limits running.
  • The case is closed but the refund has not arrived. Chase it in writing, ask for written confirmation that the penalty has been cancelled, and check that interest has been added to the refund. It runs from the date you paid the tax.
  • Your costs look high for the work involved. HMRC will only reimburse what was reasonable. Expect them to question fees they see as out of proportion, so be ready to explain why the work was needed.

What I would do

If I were in your position, I would write one clear, calm complaint and make it do the work:

  • Set out a short timeline: the return, the enquiry, the assessment and penalty, your responses, and HMRC’s concession.
  • Say plainly what was unreasonable, in particular anything HMRC have already accepted they got wrong.
  • Describe the impact on you in a few honest sentences: time, worry, disruption.
  • List every cost, with invoices, and show how each one arose from defending HMRC’s case.
  • State the remedy you want: the costs figure, and a payment for distress and inconvenience.
  • If HMRC’s final response does not resolve it, take it to the Adjudicator’s Office, which is independent and free. If that still does not resolve it, ask your MP to refer the matter to the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman.

Keep the tone factual. A documented complaint is far harder to dismiss than an angry one.

For reference

  • Finance Act 2003, Schedule 10: paragraph 12 (notice of enquiry); paragraph 28 (discovery assessments); paragraphs 35 onwards (appeals)
  • Finance Act 2003, section 89 (interest on repayment of overpaid tax)
  • HMRC Stamp Duty Land Tax Manual, SDLTM85945 (interest on repayment of overpaid tax) (HMRC’s view of the law, not the law itself)
  • Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009, rule 10 (costs orders, including for unreasonable conduct); rule 10(4) (time limit for applications)
  • HMRC Complaints and Remedies Guidance manual, sections on reimbursing costs and on worry and distress payments (HMRC’s view of the law, not the law itself)
  • The Adjudicator’s Office and the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman (escalation routes)

Related questions

Work through your own facts with an AI

An AI will give you plenty of information. It will not take responsibility for any of it. When a conveyancing solicitor asks for professional tax advice, responsibility is what they are really asking for: a named adviser who has looked at your facts and carries indemnity insurance for the view they reach.Nick Garner

The page above gives you the principle. Your own facts decide the answer. The prompt below gives an AI the reasoning I use on this question and the law that decides it, and tells it to ask you questions rather than guess.

Copy it into ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini and fill in the part in square brackets. If it shows that your case depends on a genuinely uncertain point, or your solicitor wants formal advice, it will write a short summary for you to send me.

What comes back is information, not advice. Check it against the references above.

Your AI prompt: copy it into ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini
I want help with a UK Stamp Duty Land Tax question about my own purchase. The purchase was in England or Northern Ireland. Treat the law as at November 2026.

MY SITUATION
[Write what HMRC challenged and why, what they issued (enquiry notice, assessment, penalty), how the dispute ended, whether it reached the tribunal, what HMRC have now accepted in writing, the costs you paid and who to, and how the matter affected you.]

THE QUESTION
After HMRC dropped an SDLT enquiry, can I claim compensation from HMRC?

HOW A SPECIALIST ANSWERS THIS
Source: https://landtaxadvice.co.uk/questions/can-i-claim-compensation-from-hmrc-for-a-wrongful-sdlt-enquiry. Use this reasoning as your starting point, and check it against the law below.

*The routes*
- In theory there are legal routes against HMRC (for example judicial review or a civil claim). In practice they are rarely proportionate: slow, costly, uncertain, and the bar is high.
- The sensible route is usually a formal complaint to HMRC, asking for redress and reimbursement of costs.
- If the appeal had been notified to the First-tier Tribunal, a costs application under the tribunal rules is a separate route, available where HMRC acted unreasonably in bringing, defending or conducting the proceedings (or where the case was allocated to the complex category and the taxpayer did not opt out of costs shifting). The application must be made no later than 28 days after the tribunal sends the decision notice, or the notice of a withdrawal that ends the proceedings (rule 10(4)). It is aimed at the costs of the proceedings.

*The tests*
- HMRC's complaints guidance aims to restore the taxpayer to the position they would have been in without HMRC's error. It is not punitive.
- Winning the tax argument is not, by itself, enough. HMRC do not usually pay costs where there was a genuine disagreement about the law. They look for a mistake, unreasonable delay, poor handling, or a case pursued when HMRC's own position was plainly wrong.
- Where HMRC have accepted in writing that they got something wrong (for example, that a notice, assessment or penalty should not have been issued), that is an HMRC error and a stronger basis for a complaint than a lost argument.
- In the specialist's view, where the taxpayer's position was plainly correct, HMRC's approach may have caused unnecessary distress and disruption, avoidable professional fees and other reasonable costs of defending the case.

*What can be claimed*
- Reimbursement of reasonable, evidenced costs caused by HMRC's approach, including professional fees for an adviser or accountant.
- A separate payment for worry, distress and inconvenience. These payments are modest and harder to quantify.
- Costs must be reasonable in amount and must flow from HMRC's error, not from work the taxpayer would have done anyway.

*The order of events*
- Step 1: complain to HMRC in writing, with a short timeline, what was unreasonable about their approach, the impact, the costs incurred and the remedy wanted. HMRC may review a first response internally before giving a final response.
- Step 2: if HMRC's final response does not resolve it, escalate to the Adjudicator's Office (independent and free). Check its current time limit for referrals.
- Step 3: if still unresolved, ask your MP to refer the matter to the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman. Check its current time limits.

*Common traps*
- Treating a complaint as a substitute for an appeal. A complaint does not decide whether tax is due and does not stop appeal time limits running. If the assessment or penalty has not been formally withdrawn, deal with that first.
- Assuming the penalty falls away without confirmation. Ask HMRC to confirm in writing that the assessment and penalty are cancelled.
- Not checking the refund. Confirm the amount and whether interest on the repayment has been added; repayment interest runs from the date the tax was paid.
- Overstating distress or claiming unreasonable fees. This weakens the stronger parts of the claim.
- An angry or lengthy complaint. A short, factual, documented one is more effective.

*Evidence*
- The big challenge is evidence. Costs are usually the strongest head of loss: keep invoices, engagement letters and a note of what each piece of work was for.
- Distress is real but harder to value. Explain it clearly and support it as well as possible, for example with a short account of time spent, disruption and any effect on health or work.
- Keep HMRC's concession letter, the review outcome, and all correspondence.

*Background, if relevant*
- The complaints route works the same way whatever the underlying tax point.

THE LAW THIS TURNS ON
- Finance Act 2003, Schedule 10, paragraph 12 (notice of enquiry), paragraph 28 (discovery assessments), paragraphs 35 onwards (appeals and reviews).
- Finance Act 2003, section 89: interest on repayment of overpaid tax, running from the date the tax was paid. HMRC's manual SDLTM85945 gives HMRC's view; it is not law.
- Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009, rule 10 (costs), including rule 10(4) (applications no later than 28 days after the decision notice or the notice of a withdrawal ending the proceedings).
- HMRC Complaints and Remedies Guidance manual, sections on reimbursing costs and worry and distress payments. This is HMRC's view and practice, not law.
- The Adjudicator's Office and the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman: independent complaint bodies, not courts.

WORK THROUGH THIS WITH ME
1. Ask me for any facts you need that I have not given, one question at a time. In particular: exactly what HMRC have conceded and in what words; whether my appeal was notified to the tribunal; whether the assessment and penalty have been formally cancelled; what costs I incurred, when and for what work; whether I have already complained and what HMRC replied; and how the matter affected me.
2. Apply the law and HMRC's complaints guidance to my facts, distinguishing HMRC errors from genuine disagreements about the law.
3. Give your conclusion with reasons: which route fits, what I can realistically claim, and a draft outline of my complaint.
4. Say how confident you are and what could change the answer.

THEN TELL ME WHERE I STAND
- If the answer is clear on my facts, say so plainly.
- If it turns on a genuinely uncertain point, a large amount of tax is at stake, or my solicitor has asked for formal tax advice, say so. Then write me a short summary to send to a specialist: my facts, your conclusion and reasons, the points of doubt, and the documents I have.

This is information, not advice. HMRC guidance is not law. If your training data may not cover the latest law, say so, and do not guess.

Free informal view

Find out where you stand

Email me the facts, with any documents and correspondence, and the summary from the prompt above if you used it. I will find out what is needed and give you my informal view, free of charge, so you know where you stand before deciding what, if anything, should follow.

If you or your conveyancer need advice you can rely on, a formal Letter of Advice is a separate piece of work, from £350 with no VAT. I will tell you whether one is worth having, and the fee, before anything starts.

Email [email protected]Call 0204 577 3323

Browse by topic

For advice on your own purchase, see stamp duty advice from a specialist tax adviser. Every question is listed on the questions and answers site map, or search the site.