HMRC Enquiries, Penalties and Appeals
HMRC can check an SDLT return, an amendment or a claim, and assess more tax where they find it was wrong.
The time limits, the penalty that may apply and the route of appeal all depend on what happened and when. An HMRC letter usually carries a deadline.
Every enquiry is answered by me personally.
Nick Garner, land tax adviser and registered tax agent
The rules that decide most questions
| Point | The rule |
|---|---|
| Enquiry window | 9 months from the filing date where the return was filed on time; later where it was filed late or amended (Sch 10 para 12). |
| Discovery assessments | Outside an enquiry, HMRC can assess within 4 years of the effective date, 6 years where the loss of tax was careless and 20 years where it was deliberate (Sch 10 para 31). |
| Penalties | For an inaccuracy: up to 30% of the extra tax where careless, 70% where deliberate and 100% where deliberate and concealed, reduced for disclosure. No penalty is due where reasonable care was taken (FA 2007 Sch 24). |
| Appeals | Notice of appeal to HMRC within 30 days of the closure notice or assessment, then an HMRC review or an appeal to the First-tier Tribunal (Sch 10 para 36). |
Law as at November 2026. Finance Act 2003 unless stated. A summary only: the answer in any case depends on its facts.
Questions and answers (22)
Each answer is drawn from a real question, with identifying details removed. Open a subject to see its questions.
HMRC enquiries and appeals8
- Can I Appeal an SDLT Closure Notice and Postpone the Tax?
- Can I Appeal an SDLT Closure Notice and Postpone the Tax?
- Can I Challenge HMRC's SDLT Decision After a Failed Review?
- SDLT Claim Rejected: Must I Attend HMRC's Penalty Meeting?
- SDLT Closure Notice Review: Can HMRC Extend the Deadline?
- SDLT Compliance Check: Can My Refund Claim Bring a Penalty?
- SDLT Enquiry: Can I Ask HMRC for Extra Time to Reply?
- SDLT Review Conclusion Never Arrived: Can I Appeal Late?
Refunds and amendments6
- Can WRA Reopen My LTT Enquiry After a Closure Notice?
- Company SDLT Mixed-Use Reclaim: Can HMRC Charge 17%?
- SDLT Refund Firm and Money Laundering Rules: Am I at Risk?
- SDLT Review or Reclaim: Which Documents Do I Need?
- Stamp Duty Reclaim Review: What Are the Next Steps?
- Welsh LTT Refund Paid: Can the WRA Still Open an Enquiry?
Other questions8
- HMRC Denied SDLT Multiple Dwellings Relief: Can I Appeal?
- Unsigned SDLT MDR Claim: Can HMRC Take the Refund Back?
- SDLT Enquiry Dropped: Can I Claim Compensation From HMRC?
- SDLT Enquiry Window: Does a Corrective Return Restart It?
- LTT Penalty and Interest Letter: Can I Ask WRA for a Review?
- SDLT Scheme Discovery Assessment: Must I Pay the Interest?
- What SDLT Documents and Evidence Do I Need for a Review?
- LBTT Review: Should I Agree to Extend the 45-Day Deadline?
Official guidance (26)
The official guidance on this topic, each page explained in plain English with a link to the original. All topics are on the HMRC guidance index.
All guidance pages on this topic26
- Compliance Interest: Tax Payment Dates, Rates, and Bankruptcy Implications Explained
- Compliance Introduction: Content, Readership, Interest, and Penalties Overview
- Compliance Liaison: Research, Valuation Responsibility, and General Information Overview
- Compliance Penalties and Interest: Penalties, Interest, and Relevant Date Information
- Definition and Responsibilities of Companies for Stamp Duty Land Tax Compliance
- Errors in HMRC Documents Don't Invalidate SDLT Assessments if Substantially Correct
- Guidance on Representative Partners in Ordinary Partnership Transactions for SDLT Compliance
- Guidance on SDLT Compliance, Enquiries, and Appeals Procedures for Land Transactions
- Guidance on Stamp Duty Land Tax Relief for Planning Obligations Compliance
- Guide on Appealing HMRC's Refusal of Deferred Payment Application
- Guide on HMRC Enquiries into Group Relief Claims for Land Transactions
- Guide on Penalties and Interest for Stamp Duty Land Tax Compliance
- Guide on Valuation Procedures for Compliance and Enquiry Cases in the UK
- Guide to Identifying "V" and "P" for Section 75A Compliance
- Guide to SDLT Payment Deadlines, Penalties, and Available Relief Options
- Guidelines for Handling Mis-directed Responses to Information Requests in Compliance Cases
- Interest and Penalties for Late or Incorrect Land Transaction Returns
- Interest on Overpaid Tax Repayments: HMRC Procedures and Further Information
- Interest on Unpaid Tax: Relevant Dates and Exceptions Explained
- Late Tax Return Penalty for Partnership; Partner D Jointly Liable
- Overpayment Relief Exclusions: Case D Claims and Tribunal Appeal Determinations
- Overpayment Relief Unavailable if Grounds Not Raised in Tribunal or Court Appeal
- Overpayment Relief: Discovery Assessments - Archived Information Page
- Partnership Land Transfer: Calculating Chargeable Consideration for SDLT Compliance
- Reliefs: Planning Obligations Compliance and Scottish Land Tax Changes
- Understanding Linked Transactions for Stamp Duty Land Tax Compliance and Reporting
Free informal view
Find out where you stand
Email me the facts, with any documents and correspondence. I will find out what is needed and give you my informal view, free of charge, so you know where you stand before deciding what, if anything, should follow.
If you or your conveyancer need advice you can rely on, a formal Letter of Advice is a separate piece of work, from £350 with no VAT. I will tell you whether one is worth having, and the fee, before anything starts.
Other topics
- Higher rates
- Mixed use and non-residential
- Refunds and amendments
- Companies, partnerships and trusts
- Leases
- Reliefs and first-time buyers
- Gifts, family transfers and separation
- Land Transaction Tax in Wales
- LBTT in Scotland




