Question
SDLT Claim Rejected: Must I Attend HMRC’s Penalty Meeting?
The short answer
No. HMRC can ask to meet you, but I know of no rule that makes you attend, or that requires penalty questions to be answered out loud. A rejected claim is not the same as a careless one, because the penalty turns on whether you took reasonable care. So offer to answer everything fully in writing, and ask HMRC to say exactly what they think was careless.
Answered by Nick Garner, from a question emailed to me.
Land tax adviser and registered tax agent. Every enquiry is answered by me personally.
Law as at November 2026.
Your situation
You bought a house in England, yourself or through a company, in very poor condition. Later you amended the stamp duty return (Stamp Duty Land Tax, or SDLT) to claim the lower non-residential rates, on the footing that the property was not suitable for use as a dwelling. HMRC have rejected the claim.
Now a letter says they are considering a penalty for carelessness. It invites you to a video meeting about your behaviour in making the claim, and may enclose HMRC’s factsheet on the Human Rights Act and penalties. That is unsettling, particularly if you made the claim openly and believed it was right.
My answer, and why
You do not have to attend. HMRC are entitled to ask for a meeting, but a request is not a power to compel. A careless penalty can be up to 30% of the tax you tried to reclaim, so how you answer matters.
Two separate questions
The first is whether HMRC are right to reject the claim. The second is whether, even if it fails, HMRC can properly say you were careless in making it.
On the first, I should be candid. Since the Court of Appeal decided Mudan v HMRC [2025] EWCA Civ 799, these claims face a very high bar, and HMRC challenge them firmly. In Mudan the house needed complete rewiring, a new boiler and a kitchen stripped back to the walls, and it was still a dwelling. “Suitable for use” does not mean ready to move into. A building stays residential unless it has lost its identity as a dwelling, as an empty shell with no main roof may have done. A run-down house needing a lot of work has not. HMRC’s manual says only a very limited number of properties will qualify, so anyone still considering a claim should take great care.
A failed claim is not the same as a careless one
The penalty rules are there to punish behaviour, not wrong answers. A penalty arises only if the inaccuracy was careless, meaning you failed to take reasonable care. HMRC’s own factsheet says that if you took reasonable care and the return was still wrong, no penalty is due. That is the important point.
Reasonable care is judged on your circumstances at the time: what evidence you had, what enquiries you made, any advice you took, and how openly you made the claim. Honest belief helps, but does not settle it on its own. And the fact that HMRC paid nothing does not prevent a penalty. It is worked out on the repayment that would have been made.
Why I prefer writing
Once a penalty is being considered, the meeting is no longer about the tax. It is about you. Questions on why you thought the claim was valid and what you relied on are evidence on carelessness. Spoken answers can be incomplete, oversimplified or recorded in a way you would not recognise. In writing you can check your records, and there is a clear record if the matter reaches a tribunal.
HMRC’s factsheet CC/FS9 says that where penalties are being considered you need not answer questions that may expose you to one. You should not need to lean on that. You are not refusing to answer; you are offering to answer everything in writing. Existing documents are different: where HMRC have a legal power to ask for them, you must provide them.
One honest cost: HMRC may reduce your credit for co-operation because you declined the meeting. In my view that should not follow if you answer fully in writing, but expect it to be argued.
What would change the answer
- HMRC issue a formal information notice. You must then provide the information and documents it specifies. It cannot require you to attend a meeting.
- You have already attended. Ask for HMRC’s note of the meeting and correct anything inaccurate in writing. Then ask HMRC to explain why your conduct was careless, as distinct from why the claim was wrong.
- A specialist advised on or made the claim. If you gave them the full facts and reasonably followed their advice, that is relevant to reasonable care, though not automatically a complete answer.
- HMRC allege the inaccuracy was deliberate. That is a more serious footing, and I would take advice before replying.
What I would do
If I were in your position, I would:
- Reply briefly and politely. Say you have read CC/FS7A and CC/FS9, that you would prefer to deal with questions about your actions in writing, and that you will answer them fully and promptly. No apology, and no long legal argument.
- Ask HMRC to set out their questions and identify the specific act or omission they say was a failure to take reasonable care.
- Keep supplying documents and factual answers. Leave nothing unanswered.
- Write a factual, dated account of how the claim came about, checked line by line against your records. Keep facts separate from legal argument, and avoid loose phrases such as “I thought it was worth a try”.
- Remember that a letter explaining a proposed penalty is not a bill. If HMRC assess one, you can ask for a review or appeal to the First-tier Tribunal, and ask for it to be suspended.
For reference
- Finance Act 2003, section 116(1)(a) (residential property: building suitable for use as a dwelling); Schedule 10, paragraph 6 (amending a return)
- Finance Act 2007, Schedule 24: paragraph 1 (inaccurate documents); paragraph 3 (careless means failure to take reasonable care); paragraphs 4 and 10 (penalty ranges and reductions); paragraph 5 (potential lost revenue); paragraph 14 (suspension); paragraphs 15 to 17 (appeals); paragraph 18 (agents)
- Finance Act 2008, Schedule 36, paragraph 1 (information notices)
- Mudan v HMRC [2025] EWCA Civ 799, paragraphs 64, 66 and 69
- HMRC Stamp Duty Land Tax Manual, SDLTM00385 (HMRC’s view of the law, not the law itself)
- HMRC factsheets CC/FS7A (penalties for inaccuracies) and CC/FS9 (the Human Rights Act and penalties) (HMRC’s view of the law, not the law itself)
Related questions
Work through your own facts with an AI
An AI will give you plenty of information. It will not take responsibility for any of it. When a conveyancing solicitor asks for professional tax advice, responsibility is what they are really asking for: a named adviser who has looked at your facts and carries indemnity insurance for the view they reach.Nick Garner
The page above gives you the principle. Your own facts decide the answer. The prompt below gives an AI the reasoning I use on this question and the law that decides it, and tells it to ask you questions rather than guess.
Copy it into ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini and fill in the part in square brackets. If it shows that your case depends on a genuinely uncertain point, or your solicitor wants formal advice, it will write a short summary for you to send me.
What comes back is information, not advice. Check it against the references above.
I want help with a UK Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) question about my own transaction. SDLT applies in England and Northern Ireland. Treat the law as at November 2026. MY SITUATION [Write: who bought (you or a company), when you bought, when and how the amendment or refund claim was made and by whom, what evidence of the property's condition you had at the time, any advice you took before claiming, what HMRC have said in their letters, and whether you have already attended any meeting.] THE QUESTION My SDLT claim was rejected: must I attend HMRC's penalty meeting? HOW A SPECIALIST ANSWERS THIS Source: https://landtaxadvice.co.uk/questions/do-i-have-to-attend-an-hmrc-penalty-meeting-about-my-sdlt-claim. Use this reasoning as your starting point, and check it against the law below. *The underlying claim* - Be candid with me. Since Mudan v HMRC [2025] EWCA Civ 799, a claim that a property was not suitable for use as a dwelling faces a very high bar, and HMRC challenge these claims firmly. In Mudan the house needed complete rewiring, a new boiler and pipework, and a kitchen stripped back to the walls, and it was still a dwelling. Suitable for use does not mean suitable for immediate use (para 66). A building remains a dwelling unless it has lost its fundamental characteristics as a dwelling (para 64). The court endorsed the Upper Tribunal's guidance (para 69): a dilapidated desirable house is likely to be a dwelling; an empty shell with no main roof is not. - HMRC's manual SDLTM00385 says the bar is very high and only a very limited number of properties will qualify. - Do not tell me which facts would help a claim. This conversation is about the penalty. *Two separate issues* - Issue one: whether HMRC are right to reject the claim. Issue two: whether, even if the claim fails, HMRC can show I was careless. Keep them apart. - An unsuccessful amendment does not automatically mean carelessness. Careless means failure to take reasonable care (Schedule 24 para 3). HMRC's factsheet CC/FS7A says that if reasonable care was taken but the return was still wrong, no inaccuracy penalty is due. - Reasonable care is judged on my circumstances at the time: evidence available, enquiries made, advice taken, how openly the claim was made. Honest belief alone is not conclusive. - A penalty can apply even if HMRC paid nothing: potential lost revenue is measured on the repayment that would have been made. *The meeting* - HMRC may ask for a meeting, but a request is not a power to compel. A Schedule 36 information notice can require information and documents, not attendance. - Once a penalty is being considered, questions about why I believed the claim valid, what I understood and what advice I relied on are penalty-sensitive. Facts, documents, the property's condition and the chronology are not, and I should co-operate fully on those. - CC/FS9 says that where penalties are being considered I may decline to answer questions that may expose me to one. Existing documents differ where HMRC have a legal power to request them. - In the specialist's view, do not lead with the right to silence or Article 6. The better position is: I will answer every question, including follow-ups, fully in writing. - Practical reasons for writing: spoken answers can be incomplete, oversimplified, misunderstood or misrecorded; written answers can be checked against records and form a clear record for any tribunal. - If live questioning would affect my ability to answer accurately, I can say so and ask to deal with matters in writing. - If I have already agreed to or rescheduled a meeting, I can still ask now for a written process. A short sentence is enough. - If I have already attended: ask for HMRC's note, correct inaccuracies in writing, and ask HMRC to explain why the conduct was careless as distinct from why the claim was wrong. - Honest cost: HMRC may reduce co-operation credit for declining the meeting. In the specialist's view that should not follow where every question is answered fully in writing, but it may be argued. *The reply* - Short and polite: I have read CC/FS7A and CC/FS9, I prefer to deal with conduct questions in writing, please send the questions and identify the specific act or omission said to be a failure to take reasonable care, and I will answer promptly. If HMRC say attendance or verbal answers are compulsory, ask neutrally for the authority. - No long technical submission, no apology, no over-explaining. *The factual account* - A dated, factual statement: property condition, evidence available, enquiries made, advice received, what I understood, how the claim was submitted, warnings received, later dealings with HMRC. Keep legal argument separate. - Avoid phrases such as 'I thought it was worth a try', 'I assumed uninhabitable meant non-residential', 'I knew the law was against me', and speculation about past thinking. Never conceal or misstate anything; if asked who helped (advisers, templates, AI), answer truthfully. - Points worth recording if true: I made the claim openly with supporting evidence; the SDLT was paid in full on completion; it was not part of an avoidance arrangement; I have co-operated. - If an agent made the claim, para 18 matters: was it reasonable to rely on them, given what they were told? - If I use AI to organise my account, it must not add facts; check every line against records. *If a penalty is assessed* - A letter explaining a proposed penalty is not an assessment. Careless prompted penalties range from 15% to 30% of potential lost revenue, depending on telling, helping and giving access. Check HMRC's figures. - If I appeal the closure notice on the tax and win, the penalty falls away. - After assessment: HMRC review, then appeal to the First-tier Tribunal. Consider whether this is proportionate to the amount. - Suspension (para 14): conditions must be specific and measurable, such as taking written specialist SDLT advice before any future repayment claim. THE LAW THIS TURNS ON - Finance Act 2003, section 116(1)(a); Schedule 10, paragraph 6 (amended returns). - Finance Act 2007, Schedule 24: paras 1, 3, 4, 5, 10, 13, 14, 15 to 17, 18. - Finance Act 2008, Schedule 36, paragraph 1. - Mudan v HMRC [2025] EWCA Civ 799, paras 8, 64, 66, 68, 69. - HMRC SDLTM00385; HMRC factsheets CC/FS7A and CC/FS9 (HMRC's view of the law, not the law itself). WORK THROUGH THIS WITH ME 1. Ask me for any facts you need that I have not given, one question at a time. In particular: what HMRC's letters say, whether any information notice has been issued, what evidence and advice I had before claiming, who submitted the claim, whether I have attended a meeting, and whether the buyer was me or a company. 2. Apply the law to my facts, keeping the tax issue and the penalty issue separate. 3. Give your conclusion with reasons, including the possible penalty range in figures. 4. Say how confident you are and what could change the answer. THEN TELL ME WHERE I STAND - If the answer is clear on my facts, say so plainly. - If it turns on a genuinely uncertain point, a large amount of tax is at stake, or my solicitor has asked for formal tax advice, say so. Then write me a short summary to send to a specialist: my facts, your conclusion and reasons, the points of doubt, and the documents I have. This is information, not advice. HMRC guidance is not law. If your training data may not cover the latest law, say so, and do not guess.
Free informal view
Find out where you stand
Email me the facts, with any documents and correspondence, and the summary from the prompt above if you used it. I will find out what is needed and give you my informal view, free of charge, so you know where you stand before deciding what, if anything, should follow.
If you or your conveyancer need advice you can rely on, a formal Letter of Advice is a separate piece of work, from £350 with no VAT. I will tell you whether one is worth having, and the fee, before anything starts.
Browse by topic
- Higher rates
- Mixed use and non-residential
- Refunds and amendments
- Companies, partnerships and trusts
- Leases
- Reliefs and first-time buyers
- Gifts, family transfers and separation
- HMRC enquiries, penalties and appeals
- Land Transaction Tax in Wales
- LBTT in Scotland
For advice on your own purchase, see stamp duty advice from a specialist tax adviser. Every question is listed on the questions and answers site map, or search the site.




