Mudan v HMRC [2025] EWCA Civ 799: When Is a House Suitable for Use as a Dwelling?
In Mudan v HMRC the Court of Appeal held that a structurally sound house, recently lived in but needing rewiring, a new heating system, a new kitchen and other works, was residential property for Stamp Duty Land Tax.
Every enquiry is answered by me personally.
A building is "suitable for use as a dwelling" if it has kept its character as a dwelling; it does not have to be ready to move into.
The decision is binding on the tribunals and the High Court. It is now the leading authority on whether a property in poor condition can be taxed at non-residential rates, and it makes that argument very difficult except on extreme facts.
Law as at November 2026.
The case at a glance
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Citation | Amarjeet and Tajinder Mudan v The Commissioners for HMRC [2025] EWCA Civ 799 |
| Court | Court of Appeal (Civil Division), on appeal from the Upper Tribunal [2024] UKUT 307 (TCC), which had upheld the First-tier Tribunal [2023] UKFTT 317 (TC) |
| Judges | Lewison LJ, with whom Lewis LJ and Holgate LJ agreed |
| Dates | Heard 19 June 2025; judgment handed down 27 June 2025 |
| Result | Appeal dismissed. The house was residential property. HMRC succeeded at every level. |
The facts
Mr and Mrs Mudan bought a large detached house in a residential street in London SE3 on 5 August 2019. They paid SDLT on the basis that it was residential property, then claimed a partial repayment on the basis that it was not. HMRC enquired and issued a closure notice concluding that the house was residential. The Court of Appeal recorded that the difference between the residential and non-residential rates was of the order of £100,000.
The First-tier Tribunal found that, on the effective date, the house had been used relatively recently as a dwelling (people were living there when Mr Mudan visited in August 2018) and was structurally sound. It was not in a state that a reasonable buyer would move into straight away. Before then it would need:
- complete rewiring;
- a new boiler, pumps and gas and water pipes in the boiler house, and repairs to the boiler house roof;
- repair or replacement of leaking pipes in the cellar;
- a new kitchen, stripped back to the walls;
- repairs to broken windows, doors and locks; and
- clearance of a large amount of rubbish inside and out.
Mr Mudan accepted that the house was still residential in nature and was not falling down, but considered it unsafe for a young family because of the electrics. The purchase was partly financed by a mortgage from a lender willing to lend on the property.
The question
Section 116 of the Finance Act 2003 defines residential property as a building that is "used or suitable for use as a dwelling", or is being constructed or adapted for such use, together with its garden or grounds. The buyers argued that "suitable for use" means capable of being used as a dwelling at the effective date; a building that is merely capable of being made suitable does not qualify.
The decision and the reasoning
The Court of Appeal rejected that argument and approved the approach of the Upper Tribunal. The main points of Lewison LJ's reasoning were these.
- Not a snapshot. The purchase of a building is at least a medium-term enterprise. The assessment is not confined to a snapshot of its condition on one day; its history, and whether it has kept its identity as a dwelling, are relevant.
- Two broad categories. The Act divides all property into residential and non-residential, so each definition is necessarily broad. The definition is concerned with land use rather than occupation.
- Coherence with the rest of the definition. A building still under construction is residential property. It would be irrational for Parliament to tax a shell without a roof or floors at residential rates, but not a finished house that needs rewiring, replumbing and a new kitchen and bathroom.
- Occupation cannot be decisive. A house actually lived in is residential however dilapidated. If the vendor had stayed in occupation until completion, the buyers' argument would make the tax depend on the vendor's choice rather than the building.
- The building, not its fit-out. It is the building that must be suitable, so the focus is on its structure rather than its internal fittings.
- Ordinary meaning. An ordinary speaker would still call a former home under extensive refurbishment "residential property". In Lewison LJ's words: "If, as a matter of ordinary language, it was not residential property: what was it?"
The Upper Tribunal's guidance, now approved
The Upper Tribunal had set out the factors to consider where a building needs work. The Court of Appeal described its principles as practical and workable. In summary:
- Previous use as a dwelling is a highly relevant factor and a very strong indication that the building has the fundamental characteristics of a dwelling. The time since that use matters.
- The question is whether the building has those fundamental characteristics, including structural soundness: a dilapidated house needing updating is likely to be suitable; an empty shell with no main roof is likely not to be.
- Works needed to make a building habitable are distinguished from works to make it a pleasant place to live, such as decoration, which do not affect suitability.
- It is relevant whether the defects can be remedied, and whether the works would be so hazardous, or so threatening to the structure, that they are not viable.
- A degree of danger in occupying the building, such as the need for rewiring, is relevant but does not of itself make it unsuitable.
- Labels such as "minor repair" or "fundamental works" are not a free-standing test.
Where it sits now
As a Court of Appeal decision, Mudan binds the First-tier Tribunal, the Upper Tribunal and the High Court on the meaning of section 116. Lewison LJ reviewed the earlier tribunal decisions, including P N Bewley Ltd v HMRC [2019] UKFTT 65 (TC), Fiander and Brower v HMRC [2021] UKUT 156 (TCC), Henderson Acquisitions Ltd v HMRC [2023] UKFTT 739 (TC) and HMRC v Ridgway [2024] UKUT 36 (TCC), and described them as showing a consistent approach. Bewley, where works to an asbestos-laden bungalow were found too hazardous to be viable, fits within that approach as an unusual case.
Later decisions in Scotland under LBTT are consistent with it: in Lambert and Nago v Revenue Scotland [2026] FTSTC 2 a villa under refurbishment had never lost its identity and was residential, while in Bagshaw Ltd v Revenue Scotland [2026] FTSTC 4 buildings reduced to a derelict shell had lost their identity and were non-residential. Bagshaw is an extreme case.
The page on P N Bewley Ltd v HMRC and its impact on property investors compares the two decisions in more detail.
What it means in practice
For buyers
- A house that has been lived in and is structurally sound will be residential property even if it needs substantial modernisation and is unsafe to occupy until the work is done. Budget for residential rates, and for the higher rates where they apply.
- An intention to renovate, demolish or redevelop does not change the classification on the effective date.
- A repayment claim on the basis that a property was unsuitable for use as a dwelling is very unlikely to succeed after Mudan. HMRC can enquire into an amended return or a claim, and an unfounded claim can lead to the repayment being recovered with interest and, where reasonable care was not taken, a penalty.
For conveyancers
- Where a client or a third party proposes that a property in poor condition be returned as non-residential, Mudan is the starting point. The condition of the fittings, the need for rewiring or heating, and the lender's position will rarely change the answer.
- A building that has lost its identity as a dwelling, for example a structural shell, is a different question of fact. Record the evidence of the building's state and history on the file if that question genuinely arises.
- Where the treatment is in real doubt, a written specialist opinion gives the file a documented basis for the return.
The judgment
- Mudan v HMRC [2025] EWCA Civ 799 (National Archives)
- Mudan v HMRC [2024] UKUT 307 (TCC) (National Archives)
Free informal view
Find out where you stand
Email me the facts, with any documents and correspondence. I will find out what is needed and give you my informal view, free of charge, so you know where you stand before deciding what, if anything, should follow.
If you or your conveyancer need advice you can rely on, a formal Letter of Advice is a separate piece of work, from £350 with no VAT. I will tell you whether one is worth having, and the fee, before anything starts.




