Hyman v HMRC [2022] EWCA Civ 185: No Size Limit on Garden or Grounds

In Hyman v HMRC, heard with Goodfellow v HMRC, the Court of Appeal held that there is no size limit on the "garden or grounds" of a dwelling for Stamp Duty Land Tax.

Every enquiry is answered by me personally.

Land is not excluded from residential property because it is more than the house reasonably needs, and the capital gains tax test of land "required for the reasonable enjoyment" of a residence does not apply.

Whether a particular piece of land is part of the garden or grounds remains a question of fact, decided by weighing all the circumstances. Hyman removed one argument for mixed-use treatment; it did not decide what grounds are in every case.

Law as at November 2026.

The case at a glance

ItemDetail
CitationHyman v HMRC; Goodfellow v HMRC [2022] EWCA Civ 185
CourtCourt of Appeal (Civil Division), on appeal from the Upper Tribunal (Morgan J and Judge Cannan)
JudgesLewison LJ, with whom Simler LJ and Snowden LJ agreed
DatesHeard 8 February 2022; judgment handed down 17 February 2022
ResultAppeals dismissed. All the land was residential property. HMRC succeeded.

The facts

  • Mr and Mrs Hyman bought The Farmhouse, near St Albans, on 23 October 2015: a house with 3.5 acres comprising a cultivated garden, a secondary garden, a barn in poor repair and, for the most part, a meadow, with a bridleway along one side.
  • Dr and Mrs Goodfellow bought Heathermoor House, near Fordingbridge in Hampshire, on 21 March 2016: a house with 4.5 acres including gardens, a swimming pool, garaging, a stable yard and paddocks.

Both sets of buyers argued that part of their land went beyond what the house needed and so was not residential property, making the purchase mixed use and taxable at the lower non-residential rates. The tax at stake was £34,950 for the Hymans and £48,500 for the Goodfellows. In each case the First-tier Tribunal found, as a question of fact, that all the land was garden or grounds, and the Upper Tribunal upheld that.

The question

Section 116(1)(b) of the Finance Act 2003 includes in residential property "land that is or forms part of the garden or grounds" of a dwelling. The taxpayers did not challenge the factual findings. Their argument was that, whatever "garden or grounds" means, there is an objective limit: only land needed for the reasonable enjoyment of the dwelling, having regard to its size and nature, can count.

They relied on HMRC's guidance on the earlier stamp duty disadvantaged areas relief (SP 1/03, April 2003), which applied a test similar to the capital gains tax main residence relief in section 222 of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992, and on a ministerial statement made during the passage of the Finance Act 2002.

The decision and the reasoning

Lewison LJ rejected the argument for these reasons.

  • The words are clear. The statute contains no such limitation. Parliament often uses coarse-grained words whose outer limits are left to the courts and tribunals. Whether a more prescriptive test would be desirable is a question of policy.
  • The ministerial statement was inadmissible. The conditions in Pepper v Hart [1993] AC 593 were not met: the statement did not express a view on what the draft legislation meant, and concerned a different question.
  • The stamp duty guidance did not carry over. SP 1/03 did not exist, even in draft, while the Bill was before Parliament. It was given for stamp duty, not SDLT, which is an entirely new tax. It did not purport to interpret the legislation, and it gave no reasons for borrowing a capital gains tax test. It could be given no significant weight, and HMRC's interpretation was "simply wrong".
  • The capital gains tax test does a different job. Section 222 limits the amount of garden or grounds that qualifies for a relief, with a 0.5 hectare default; land outside the permitted area is still garden or grounds. Section 116 classifies property as residential or non-residential for all SDLT purposes. As Lewison LJ put it: "Land does not cease to be residential property merely because the occupier of a dwelling house could do without it."

Implying the limitation would mean grafting onto the Act a provision that is not there, which the court could not do.

Where it sits now

Hyman is binding on the First-tier Tribunal, the Upper Tribunal and the High Court. Every later decision on garden or grounds starts from it. The Upper Tribunal has since confirmed that the question is a multi-factorial evaluation of all the facts:

  • The How Development 1 Ltd v HMRC [2023] UKUT 84 (TCC): about two acres of woodland that was hard to access was part of the grounds.
  • HMRC v Suterwalla [2024] UKUT 188 (TCC): a separately titled paddock, screened from the house, was not part of the grounds on the facts found. See the Suterwalla page.
  • HMRC v Brzezicki [2026] UKUT 125 (TCC): a stream and island were part of the grounds, applying Hyman's point that grounds need not be necessary to the enjoyment of the dwelling.

The factors most often weighed include historic and current use, layout, proximity and contiguity, extent, common ownership, accessibility, privacy and security, and legal rights over the land. No single factor decides the case. HMRC's own guidance on the point was revised in 2019.

What it means in practice

For buyers

  • The size of the land alone will not make a purchase mixed use. A large garden, paddock or meadow sold with a house is likely to be treated as grounds unless something about its use or character separates it from the house.
  • Where land beyond the garden is in genuine separate use, for example under an existing agricultural or commercial arrangement, the classification can differ. That is a question of evidence about the land as it stood at completion, not about what the buyer needed or intended.
  • HMRC can enquire into a return or a claim, and a failed claim can lead to the tax being recovered with interest and, where reasonable care was not taken, a penalty.

For conveyancers

  • Do not file on a mixed-use basis because the land exceeds 0.5 hectares or what the house "needs". That argument was rejected in Hyman.
  • Where mixed use is proposed, ask what the land was used for at completion, by whom, and on what legal basis, and keep that evidence on the file.

The judgment

Free informal view

Find out where you stand

Email me the facts, with any documents and correspondence. I will find out what is needed and give you my informal view, free of charge, so you know where you stand before deciding what, if anything, should follow.

If you or your conveyancer need advice you can rely on, a formal Letter of Advice is a separate piece of work, from £350 with no VAT. I will tell you whether one is worth having, and the fee, before anything starts.

Email [email protected]Call 0204 577 3323

Related pages