HMRC v Suterwalla [2024] UKUT 188 (TCC): A Paddock Outside the Grounds
In HMRC v Suterwalla the Upper Tribunal upheld a First-tier Tribunal finding that a paddock bought with a family house near Henley on Thames was not part of its grounds, so the purchase was mixed use and the lower non-residential rates applied.
Every enquiry is answered by me personally.
HMRC's appeal was dismissed.
The Upper Tribunal also said, without needing to decide the point, that a grazing lease the buyers granted after completion should have been left out of account: the question is the character of the land as it stood at completion. The result turned on the First-tier Tribunal's findings of fact, and the Upper Tribunal declined to interfere with them; it is not authority that paddocks are generally outside the grounds.
Law as at November 2026.
The case at a glance
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Citation | The Commissioners for HMRC v Mr Taher Suterwalla and Mrs Zahra Suterwalla [2024] UKUT 188 (TCC) |
| Court | Upper Tribunal (Tax and Chancery Chamber), on HMRC's appeal from the First-tier Tribunal |
| Judges | Judge Greg Sinfield and Judge Ashley Greenbank |
| Dates | Heard 22 April 2024; decision released 1 July 2024 |
| Result | HMRC's appeal dismissed. The paddock was not part of the grounds; the purchase was mixed use. |
The facts
On 11 December 2020 Mr and Mrs Suterwalla bought a seven-bedroom house outside Henley on Thames with an indoor swimming pool, gardens with a pavilion and tennis court, and a paddock. Their return, filed on 14 December 2020, treated the purchase as mixed use. HMRC enquired and in November 2021 issued a closure notice increasing the tax from £169,500 to £330,750 on the basis that the whole property was residential.
The First-tier Tribunal found that:
- the property was in two registered titles, one for the house, gardens and tennis court and a separate one for the paddock;
- the sales brochure mentioned the paddock almost as an afterthought;
- the paddock was separated from the tennis court by a hedge with only a small gate, and could not be seen from the house;
- the buyers had never used the paddock, and would not have bought it if they could have bought the house without it; and
- on the day of completion they granted a neighbour a one-year grazing lease of the paddock for up to two horses at £1,000 a year. The neighbour reached it from a bridle path over common land.
The First-tier Tribunal allowed the buyers' appeal.
The questions
HMRC appealed on three grounds, which came down to two questions: whether the First-tier Tribunal was wrong to take the grazing lease into account, given that it did not exist at completion; and whether, in any event, the only conclusion open to it on the facts was that the paddock was part of the grounds.
The decision and the reasoning
The paddock, leaving the grazing lease aside
The Upper Tribunal took the second question first. Whether land forms part of the grounds is a multi-factorial evaluation, and an appellate tribunal can interfere only if the conclusion is rationally insupportable or involves an error of law. It held that the First-tier Tribunal was entitled to find that the paddock was not part of the grounds, without relying on the lease, because:
- the paddock and the house had separate titles;
- the paddock was not close to the house and could not be seen from it or the gardens;
- it was reached from the gardens only by a single small gate;
- it did not support the house, garden or tennis court; and
- it did not form an integral part of the property.
The tribunal did find one error. The buyers' preference not to have bought the paddock says nothing about the SDLT treatment of the interest they did acquire, and should not have been given weight. That error did not undermine the conclusion, which the other findings supported. The Upper Tribunal accepted that another tribunal on similar facts might have reached a different view; that was not a reason to interfere.
The grazing lease
Although it did not need to decide the point, the Upper Tribunal said that the First-tier Tribunal erred in relying on the grazing lease. The treatment of a transaction depends on the nature of the chargeable interest acquired at completion, and the lease was granted afterwards. Whether completion and the lease fell on the same "effective date" did not matter.
It added a qualification: "The subsequent use of land may be evidence of its nature or character at the time of completion." A lease granted after completion might formalise an informal arrangement with the previous owner, or reinstate a historic commercial use. Here there was no evidence of any earlier use, so the lease was an entirely new use that began after the buyers had acquired the land.
Where it sits now
Suterwalla is an Upper Tribunal decision and binds the First-tier Tribunal on the points of law it decides. It applies Hyman v HMRC [2022] EWCA Civ 185 (see the Hyman page) and sets out, with approval, a list of factors drawn from the earlier cases. That list has been applied in later decisions.
In HMRC v Brzezicki [2026] UKUT 125 (TCC) the Upper Tribunal relied on Suterwalla for the point that the land is characterised at the effective date and that later use is relevant only as evidence of its character then. It reversed a First-tier Tribunal decision that had taken account of the land's later commercial use, and held a stream and island to be part of the grounds.
The outcome in Suterwalla depended on findings of fact that the Upper Tribunal would not disturb. It shows that a paddock can fall outside the grounds; it does not show that it usually will.
What it means in practice
For buyers
- Arrangements made at or after completion, such as a new grazing licence or lease, will not by themselves turn residential land into non-residential land.
- What counts is the land as it was when bought: its title, layout, separation from the house, visibility, access and any genuine use by others at that time.
- Mixed-use treatment carries risk. HMRC can enquire into a mixed-use return, and if the land is found to be grounds the additional tax is payable with interest and, where reasonable care was not taken, a penalty.
For conveyancers
- Where a client proposes mixed-use treatment because of a paddock or field, ask for evidence of the position at completion: the titles, a plan, photographs, and any agreement for use by a third party that was already in place.
- Arrangements put in place by the vendor before completion at the buyer's request raise separate issues. See HMRC v Ridgway, where a lease granted two weeks before completion did not make a building non-residential.
The decision
Free informal view
Find out where you stand
Email me the facts, with any documents and correspondence. I will find out what is needed and give you my informal view, free of charge, so you know where you stand before deciding what, if anything, should follow.
If you or your conveyancer need advice you can rely on, a formal Letter of Advice is a separate piece of work, from £350 with no VAT. I will tell you whether one is worth having, and the fee, before anything starts.




