Inngrays Ltd v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 1478 (TC): A Substation Outside the Grounds
In Inngrays Ltd v HMRC the First-tier Tribunal held that an electricity substation at the rear garden of a Hampstead building of five flats was not part of its garden or grounds.
Every enquiry is answered by me personally.
The substation land had been let exclusively to the electricity network operator since at least 1963, and the owner was excluded from it. The purchase was therefore mixed use, and the tax in dispute was £341,750.
The decision is recent, persuasive only, and was released on 23 October 2026, so the time for HMRC to seek permission to appeal may still be running. It turns on unusual facts: complete and long-standing exclusion of the owner from a separate building. It does not suggest that cables, poles, wayleaves or other rights over a garden make a property mixed use.
Law as at November 2026.
The case at a glance
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Citation | Inngrays Limited v The Commissioners for HMRC [2026] UKFTT 1478 (TC) |
| Court | First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber) |
| Panel | Tribunal Judge Michaela Snelders and Noel Barrett |
| Dates | Heard 8 October 2026; decision released 23 October 2026 |
| Result | Appeal allowed. The substation land was not part of the grounds; the purchase was mixed use. |
The facts
- Inngrays Limited bought 59 Fitzjohns Avenue, Hampstead, for £7,750,000 on 29 May 2024: a semi-detached period building arranged as five flats, four let on assured shorthold tenancies and one vacant. It was common ground that each flat was a dwelling.
- At the rear of the land stood a brick electricity substation with a metal door marked "DANGER OF DEATH", screened by a large tree and bushes.
- The substation land was held under a separate registered leasehold title. It had been let to the London Electricity Board in 1963 for 40 years, and was let to London Power Networks plc for 20 years from 24 June 2010, with exclusive possession, use only as a transformer substation, and a rent of £1,250 a year plus VAT. The operator also had rights over adjoining land for access and maintenance, and the landlord could re-enter only for an unremedied material breach.
- The purchase was expressly subject to the tenancies and the substation lease. The return treated it as mixed use and claimed multiple dwellings relief, which was not in dispute. HMRC enquired, concluded that the property was wholly residential, and assessed a further £341,750.
The question
Was the land occupied by the substation part of the "garden or grounds" of the dwelling under section 116(1)(b) of the Finance Act 2003 at the effective date? If it was, the whole property was residential; if not, the purchase included non-residential land and the mixed-use rates applied. The burden of proof was on the company.
HMRC argued that third-party rights and commercial use do not of themselves stop land being grounds, relying in particular on Faiers v HMRC [2023] UKFTT 297 (TC), where a commercial electricity network on the land did not prevent it being grounds.
The decision and the reasoning
The tribunal applied the multi-factorial approach approved in Hyman v HMRC [2022] EWCA Civ 185 and the list of factors set out with approval in HMRC v Suterwalla [2024] UKUT 188 (TCC). It accepted HMRC's starting point that third-party rights, and even commercial use, are not of themselves conclusive. It held that the present facts went materially further, and that it was the cumulative effect of the factors that decided the case:
- Complete exclusion. The operator had exclusive possession under the lease; the owner could not use the land except on re-entry for breach, and the occupiers of the flats had no rights over it at all. In the tribunal's words: "This is not a case of some limited intrusion into residential use. It is a case of complete exclusion."
- A separate building, not cables or pipes. In Faiers, and in another tribunal decision relied on by HMRC, the infrastructure was overhead or underground and the land remained usable in the same way as the rest of the grounds. Here a separate building occupied a defined area and prevented any residential use of it.
- Part of what was bought. The substation land was part of the property acquired, unlike an earlier case about a ventilation shaft that sat outside the purchased title.
- A self-standing function. The substation did not support the flats. It formed part of a wider electricity distribution undertaking that was not compatible with residence.
- Long-standing separate occupation. The land had been occupied separately for electricity distribution for more than sixty years, so this was not recent or incidental interference.
Where it sits now
As a First-tier Tribunal decision, Inngrays binds no other tribunal. Either party could apply for permission to appeal within 56 days of the decision being sent to it; I have not been able to confirm whether HMRC have done so, and the position should be checked before the decision is relied on.
Two points of context matter. First, the decision does not refer to HMRC v Brzezicki [2026] UKUT 125 (TCC), in which the Upper Tribunal held, on its facts, that commercial or other use of a stream and island would not have been inconsistent with their being grounds, and that later use does not answer the completion-date question. Second, its reliance on a "self-standing function" test drawn from earlier First-tier Tribunal decisions should be read with the appellate cases, which treat grounds as a balanced evaluation of all the facts rather than any single test.
What it means in practice
For buyers
- A substation or similar installation on land sold with a house does not automatically make the purchase mixed use. The facts that mattered in Inngrays were exclusive possession under a long lease, a separate title, a separate building and decades of separate use.
- Wayleaves, overhead or underground cables, poles and rights of access are generally consistent with the land remaining grounds, as Faiers shows.
- A mixed-use return or repayment claim on the strength of this decision carries real risk while it stands as a single First-tier Tribunal decision that may be appealed. HMRC can enquire, and if the land is found to be grounds the tax is payable with interest and, where reasonable care was not taken, a penalty.
For conveyancers
- Where a title includes land let to a utility, obtain the lease or title entries and establish whether the operator has exclusive possession, how long the arrangement has existed, and whether the land is physically separated.
- Where mixed-use treatment is proposed on similar facts, a written specialist opinion gives the file a documented basis for the return.
The decision
Free informal view
Find out where you stand
Email me the facts, with any documents and correspondence. I will find out what is needed and give you my informal view, free of charge, so you know where you stand before deciding what, if anything, should follow.
If you or your conveyancer need advice you can rely on, a formal Letter of Advice is a separate piece of work, from £350 with no VAT. I will tell you whether one is worth having, and the fee, before anything starts.




