Guidance on LBTT Charities Relief for Land Transactions in Scotland

LBTT charities relief for Scottish land purchases

LBTT charities relief can reduce or remove Land and Buildings Transaction Tax when a qualifying charity or charitable trust buys land or buildings in Scotland for charitable use or as an investment supporting its charitable aims. The relief is not automatic, may be limited in joint purchases, and can be withdrawn if the property is later used or held for non-charitable purposes.

• The buyer must be a qualifying charity or charitable trust, and must hold or intend to hold all or most of the property for recognised charitable purposes.
• Relief is not available if the transaction is entered into to avoid LBTT, so the purpose and structure of the deal matter.
• Property held as an investment can still qualify if the profits are used for the charity’s purposes.
• Where a charity buys jointly with a non-charity, relief is based on the lower of the charity’s ownership share and its share of the purchase price.
• Relief can be clawed back in whole or in part if, usually within three years, the charity ceases to qualify or the property is used, held, transferred or leased in a way that triggers a disqualifying event.
• If a disqualifying event happens, a further LBTT return must usually be filed within 30 days and extra tax may become payable.

Scroll down for the full analysis.

LBTT charities relief: when a charity buying Scottish land can claim relief

This page explains when relief from Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (LBTT) may be available because the buyer is a charity. The relief can remove the tax entirely, or reduce it in a joint purchase. It is useful, but it is not automatic. The charity must meet specific conditions when it buys the property, and the relief can later be withdrawn if the property stops being used or held for qualifying charitable purposes.

What this rule is about

Schedule 13 to the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Scotland) Act 2013 gives relief where the buyer in a land transaction is a charity and certain conditions are met. The same relief is available to charitable trusts.

The basic idea is straightforward. If a charity acquires land or buildings to use for its charitable purposes, or to hold as an investment whose profits support those purposes, LBTT relief may be claimed. But the legislation also contains an anti-avoidance condition and clawback rules. That means you must look not only at who the buyer is, but also at why the property is being acquired, how it will be held, and what happens afterwards.

What the official source says

The official guidance says that both of the main qualifying conditions must be met:

• the charity or charitable trust must hold, or intend to hold, the subject matter of the transaction, or the greater part of it, for qualifying charitable purposes; and
• the transaction must not be entered into for the purpose of avoiding LBTT by the buyer or anyone else.

For this relief, charitable purposes are the recognised charitable purposes listed in the legislation, including matters such as the relief of poverty, advancement of education, religion, health, environmental protection, animal welfare, and other analogous purposes. The list matches section 7(2) of the Charities and Trustee Investment (Scotland) Act 2005.

A charity can qualify if it is:

• a body registered in the Scottish Charity Register maintained by OSCR; or
• a body managed or controlled outside Scotland whose purposes consist only of one or more recognised charitable purposes, and which is established under the law of the rest of the UK, another EU member state, Norway, Iceland or Liechtenstein.

The guidance notes that a non-Scottish body acquiring land in Scotland may need to register with OSCR, depending on the circumstances.

A charitable trust also qualifies. The legislation treats this as either:

• a trust all of whose beneficiaries are charities; or
• a unit trust scheme all of whose unit holders are charities.

Where a charity buys jointly with a non-charity, partial relief may be available. The relief is calculated by first working out the LBTT on the whole transaction, then applying the lower of:

• the charity’s percentage share in the property; and
• the percentage of the purchase price paid by the charity for its share.

The guidance also deals separately with certain partnership transactions under Schedule 17. In those cases, the transaction is exempt if the transferee is a charity and the qualifying conditions are met. But all chargeable interests held as partnership property immediately after the transfer must be held for qualifying charitable purposes. If some partnership property is held for charitable purposes and some is not, there is no partial relief under these partnership rules.

The relief can be withdrawn, in whole or in part, if a disqualifying event occurs. Broadly, that happens if:

• within three years of the effective date, the charity stops being established for charitable purposes only; or
• within that period, the property, or an interest or right derived from it, is used or held for non-charitable purposes; or
• after the three-year period, such an event occurs because of arrangements put in place during that three-year period, while the charity still holds the relevant chargeable interest or one derived from it.

There are also special disqualifying events where only part of the property was acquired by the charity for charitable purposes. In that case, a transfer to a non-charity, or the grant to a non-charity of a low-rental lease at a premium, can trigger withdrawal or partial withdrawal.

If a disqualifying event occurs, a further LBTT return must be made within 30 days beginning with the day after the event. The tax then due is the amount that would have been chargeable without the relief, or an appropriate proportion if only part of the relief is withdrawn.

What this means in practice

The key practical question is whether the charity is genuinely acquiring the property for qualifying charitable use or holding. The relief is not limited to direct operational use, such as a building used as a school, care facility or place of worship. It can also cover property held as an investment, provided the profits are applied to charitable purposes. That point is made expressly in the partnership section and reflects the wider structure of the relief.

The phrase “hold or intend to hold” matters. A charity does not always need to be using the property for charitable purposes on day one. But it should be able to show a real intention, at the time of purchase, that the property or the greater part of it will be held for qualifying charitable purposes.

The anti-avoidance condition is equally important. Even if the buyer is a charity, relief is not available if the transaction is entered into for the purpose of avoiding LBTT. The guidance does not set out a detailed test for this, so in practice the facts, structure and commercial reality of the transaction will matter.

Joint purchases need care. A charity does not automatically get relief on the full transaction just because it is one of the buyers. The legislation gives only a proportionate relief, and the calculation uses the lower of the charity’s ownership share and its contribution to the price. This prevents a mismatch where the charity appears to hold a large share but has funded only a smaller part of the purchase.

The clawback rules are especially important for charities, trustees and conveyancers. Relief should not be treated as a one-off filing point only. If the property’s use changes within the relevant period, or if there were arrangements in place during that period that later lead to non-charitable use, tax may become payable after the original transaction.

How to analyse it

A sensible way to approach the relief is to work through these questions:

• Is the buyer a qualifying charity or charitable trust for the purposes of Schedule 13?
• What exactly is being acquired: the whole property, part of it, or an interest through a partnership transaction?
• Will the charity hold the property, or the greater part of it, for qualifying charitable purposes?
• If the property is to be held as an investment, how will the profits be applied?
• Is there any aspect of the structure that could suggest a purpose of LBTT avoidance?
• If there are joint buyers, what percentage share will the charity hold, and what percentage of the price will it actually fund?
• Could anything planned within the next three years amount to a disqualifying event?
• If only part of the property is for charitable purposes, is there a risk that a later transfer or low-rental premium lease to a non-charity could trigger partial withdrawal?

For partnership cases, the analysis is stricter. You must ask whether every chargeable interest held by the partnership immediately after the transfer is held for qualifying charitable purposes. If the answer is no, the separate partnership relief described in the guidance is not available on a partial basis.

Example

A Scottish registered charity buys a building. It intends to use most of the building for its educational activities and a small part for administration connected with those activities. On those facts, the charity may be able to claim charities relief, because it intends to hold the greater part of the property for qualifying charitable purposes.

Now change the facts. Two years later, the charity grants part of the property to a non-charity in a way that falls within the disqualifying event rules, or begins to use part of the property for non-charitable purposes. In that situation, the original relief may be withdrawn in whole or in part, and a further LBTT return may be required within 30 days of the event.

For a joint purchase example, suppose a charity and a non-charity buy a property together. The charity takes a 40% share in the property but pays only 30% of the purchase price for its share. The relief is based on the lower figure, so the charity relief would be calculated by reference to 30% of the LBTT on the whole transaction.

Why this can be difficult in practice

Several parts of the relief are fact-sensitive.

First, the legislation requires the property, or the greater part of it, to be held for qualifying charitable purposes. In some cases that will be obvious. In others, especially mixed-use or phased-use properties, it may be less clear how the “greater part” test should be applied in practice.

Second, intention at the time of purchase can be hard to evidence if the charity’s plans are still developing. Board minutes, business plans, funding documents and internal approvals may all matter in showing what the intended charitable use really was.

Third, the anti-avoidance condition is broad. The guidance states the rule, but does not give a detailed decision framework. Transactions involving connected parties, unusual funding arrangements, or circular steps may attract closer scrutiny.

Fourth, the withdrawal rules do not only look at what happens within three years. They also catch later disqualifying events that arise from arrangements put in place during that period. That means the original planning and documentation can remain relevant after the three-year window has passed.

Finally, partial withdrawal can be difficult to calculate because the legislation requires an “appropriate proportion” having regard to what was acquired and is still held, and what is being used for non-charitable purposes. That is not a simple mechanical test in every case.

Key takeaways

• LBTT charities relief is available only if the buyer is a qualifying charity or charitable trust and the property is held, or intended to be held, for qualifying charitable purposes.
• The relief can be full or partial, but joint purchase relief is limited by the lower of the charity’s ownership share and its share of the purchase price.
• The relief can later be withdrawn if a disqualifying event occurs, so the property’s use and any later dealings with it must be monitored after completion.

This page was last updated on

Useful article? You may find it helpful to read the original guidance here: Guidance on LBTT Charities Relief for Land Transactions in Scotland

View all LBTT Guidance Pages Here